search

Autodesk / maya-usd

A common USD (Universal Scene Description) plugin for Autodesk Maya
759 stars 202 forks source link

[MAYA-126919] Request to use displayColor when disabling "Textured" in the viewport #2802

Open chrizzFTD opened 1 year ago

chrizzFTD commented 1 year ago

Hi maya-usd team, happy new year!

I was unsure if this is a bug or a feature request, so I'm logging this as a "Feature request".

Context This relates to the request from https://github.com/Autodesk/maya-usd/issues/2206 to allow a USD Stage to "listen" to the Textured control from the viewport toolbar:

image

Current Behavior

With the update from https://github.com/Autodesk/maya-usd/pull/2599, textures get disabled (good) but meshes are drawn with black color instead of drawing according to their displayColor property.

This magazines.zip zip file contains the usdz stage from entity/books_magazines01/books_magazines01.usda from the ALab phase 2.

Go to Create / Universal Scene Description (USD) / Stage From File... and select the zip file. You can see how toggling the Textured button goes from textured geometry to black geometry:

maya_disable_materials

When loading the complete ALab set, the same happens:

texture_disabled_shows_black_instead_of_displayColor

Expected Behavior

USDView and Houdini respect displayColor when disabling scene materials, which is why as a user, I would expect for Maya to do the same. In the ALab example, we can see that meshes which did not have a material previously applied, continue to draw with displayColor:

image

USDView exposes this with the Enable Scene Materials menu:

image

usdview_disable_materials

Houdini does it with the Display Materials on Objects toggle:

houdini_disable_materials

Could the Maya Textured toggle follow the same approach?

Thanks!

santosd commented 1 year ago

Hi @chrizzFTD, Thank you for reporting this. I think this would be a great addition. I will go ahead and log this internally as I believe it may require some Maya side changes.

santosd commented 1 year ago

This issue was internally logged as MAYA-126919.

wallworm commented 1 year ago

We are working to address this. Since we found that this may not accommodate those studios/users that don't want the display colors in this case, we intend to make a User Preference that will choose the behavior: Case #1, keep current behavior and Case #2 display the displayColor.

maya-usd-git-sync[bot] commented 9 months ago

Issue synced internally to EMSUSD-742

Ziethriel commented 3 months ago

We are working to address this. Since we found that this may not accommodate those studios/users that don't want the display colors in this case, we intend to make a User Preference that will choose the behavior: Case #1, keep current behavior and Case #2 display the displayColor.

Having the user preference will be nice, since we probably wouldn't want to have the vertex colors in untextured mode. However we would like to have the option to "Toggle Display Colors Attribute" like mentioned in my issue below:

https://github.com/Autodesk/maya-usd/issues/3299

Maybe the keep current behavior can add this change?

alex-savenko-at-cinesite commented 11 hours ago

The suggested solutions (#1 and #2) can only be applied to diffuseColor input of USdPreviewShader. What happens if the preview shader has connections to opacity, specularColor or any other parameter of the preview shader? It would be great if those cases could be supported too. If you are planning to use a preference option already, can you please consider supporting option #3: "fallback option".

When hardware texturing is disabled, the preview shader should use fallback parameter of the connected UsdUVTexture or UsdPrimvarReader shaders instead of using the connected shaders themselves. In other words, the shader should behave in the same way as if the specified texture or the primvar was not found.

The benefits of the option #3:

References: