Closed N6REJ closed 4 months ago
โฑ๏ธ Estimated effort to review: 4 ๐ต๐ต๐ต๐ตโช |
๐งช No relevant tests |
๐ No security concerns identified |
โก Key issues to review Code Clarity The inclusion of the `QuickPick` class and related operations significantly increases the complexity of the homepage logic. Consider modularizing this functionality into separate, more manageable components or services to improve maintainability and readability. Hardcoded Paths The code contains hardcoded directory paths (e.g., `__DIR__ . '/../../classes/actions/class.action.quickPick.php'`). This could lead to issues with portability and flexibility of the codebase. Consider using configuration files or environment variables to manage paths. Global Variables The script uses global variables extensively, which can lead to code that is harder to test and maintain. Consider refactoring to use dependency injection or a similar technique to manage dependencies more cleanly. |
Category | Suggestion | Score |
Security |
Improve security by avoiding exposure of server file paths in the title tag___ **Replace the absolute path in the tag with a relative or more generic title to avoid exposing server file paths which can be a security risk.** [api/html/d9/dbf/homepage_8php_source.html [17]](https://github.com/Bearsampp/sandbox/pull/52/files#diff-e0f77dcc96ef49015b7083308abb6afed2f1ffc78e1dd0bbd08da9beec12ee83R17-R17) ```diff - Suggestion importance[1-10]: 10Why: Exposing server file paths in the title tag can be a significant security risk. Replacing it with a more generic title improves security without affecting functionality. | 10 |
Improve security by generalizing the title to not reveal server details___ **Consider using a more generic title in the tag to avoid revealing specific file paths and server details, which can be a security concern.** [api/html/d9/dbf/homepage_8php.html [17]](https://github.com/Bearsampp/sandbox/pull/52/files#diff-3e4e78cd2ca7ed43628b1b109628c3feda794c12f3af40652b13e74afcc9f313R17-R17) ```diff - Suggestion importance[1-10]: 9Why: The suggestion improves security by removing specific file paths and server details from the title, which is a good practice to avoid revealing sensitive information. | 9 | |
Add Subresource Integrity (SRI) attributes to external scripts to enhance security___ **Ensure that all external scripts and resources have integrity attributes to preventthe risk of CDN tampering. Adding Subresource Integrity (SRI) attributes enhances security by ensuring that files fetched from a CDN haven't been tampered with.** [api/html/d7/dcf/classQuickPick.html [19]](https://github.com/Bearsampp/sandbox/pull/52/files#diff-14f4d9b2d0309e6c912ace821d145def986152d764edde6aabd6c73ee5f4b193R19-R19) ```diff - + ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 9Why: Adding SRI attributes is a crucial security measure to ensure that external scripts have not been tampered with, significantly enhancing the security of the web application. | 9 | |
Best practice |
Wrap JavaScript initialization in a DOMContentLoaded event to ensure the DOM is fully loaded before script execution___ **It's recommended to wrap the JavaScript code with a tag inside a DOMContentLoaded event listener to ensure that the script executes only after the entire HTML document has been fully loaded. This prevents potential issues where the script tries to modify DOM elements that have not yet been loaded.** [api/html/d6/de4/classUtil.html [23-25]](https://github.com/Bearsampp/sandbox/pull/52/files#diff-f13bb09c53bb2fda9fec5bd5b49f63c06d1c4e981df5111e018741030be9377eR23-R25) ```diff ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 9Why: The suggestion is correct and addresses a best practice in JavaScript to ensure that the DOM is fully loaded before executing the script. This can prevent potential issues related to DOM manipulation. | 9 |
Remove the deprecated 'X-UA-Compatible' meta tag to enhance compatibility and follow modern web standards___ **Replace the use of the deprecatedX-UA-Compatible meta tag with modern CSS and JavaScript techniques to ensure compatibility across browsers. The X-UA-Compatible tag is primarily used for legacy Internet Explorer compatibility and is not recommended for modern web applications.** [api/html/d7/dcf/classQuickPick.html [14]](https://github.com/Bearsampp/sandbox/pull/52/files#diff-14f4d9b2d0309e6c912ace821d145def986152d764edde6aabd6c73ee5f4b193R14-R14) ```diff - + ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: Removing the deprecated 'X-UA-Compatible' meta tag is a good practice for modern web development, as it is no longer necessary for modern browsers and can help streamline the HTML. | 8 | |
Ensure consistent resource path formatting to prevent path errors___ **Ensure that thegetResourcesPath() method always returns a path with a trailing slash to avoid path concatenation errors elsewhere in the code.** [api/html/d9/dbf/homepage_8php_source.html [37]](https://github.com/Bearsampp/sandbox/pull/52/files#diff-e0f77dcc96ef49015b7083308abb6afed2f1ffc78e1dd0bbd08da9beec12ee83R37-R37) ```diff -$resourcesPath = rtrim( $bearsamppHomepage->getResourcesPath(), '/' ) . '/'; +$resourcesPath = $bearsamppHomepage->getResourcesPath(); ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: Ensuring that the `getResourcesPath()` method always returns a path with a trailing slash can prevent path concatenation errors. However, this change assumes that the method is correctly implemented elsewhere. | 7 | |
Maintainability |
Use a loop to dynamically generate script tags for improved maintainability___ **Use a loop to dynamically generate script tags based on the$jsFiles array to reduce redundancy and improve maintainability.** [api/html/d9/dbf/homepage_8php_source.html [80-96]](https://github.com/Bearsampp/sandbox/pull/52/files#diff-e0f77dcc96ef49015b7083308abb6afed2f1ffc78e1dd0bbd08da9beec12ee83R80-R96) ```diff - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - + + + ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 9Why: Using a loop to dynamically generate script tags based on the `$jsFiles` array reduces redundancy and improves maintainability, making it easier to manage and update the list of scripts. | 9 |
Improve maintainability by separating JavaScript into its own file___ **Encapsulate the JavaScript code for initializing the dark mode toggle into aseparate JS file for better maintainability and separation of concerns.** [api/html/d9/dbf/homepage_8php.html [23-25]](https://github.com/Bearsampp/sandbox/pull/52/files#diff-3e4e78cd2ca7ed43628b1b109628c3feda794c12f3af40652b13e74afcc9f313R23-R25) ```diff - + + ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: Encapsulating JavaScript into a separate file enhances maintainability and separation of concerns, making the codebase easier to manage. | 8 | |
Enhancement |
Combine script tags to reduce HTML size and improve script management___ **Combine the script tags forDoxygenAwesomeDarkModeToggle.init() into a single tag to reduce the HTML size and improve readability.** [api/html/d9/dbf/homepage_8php_source.html [22-25]](https://github.com/Bearsampp/sandbox/pull/52/files#diff-e0f77dcc96ef49015b7083308abb6afed2f1ffc78e1dd0bbd08da9beec12ee83R22-R25) ```diff - - + ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: Combining the script tags for `DoxygenAwesomeDarkModeToggle.init()` into a single tag reduces HTML size and improves readability, making the code cleaner and easier to maintain. | 8 |
Enhance readability and accessibility by using a full date format for the project version___ **Update the project version display to use a more accessible format, possiblyincluding the full date for clarity.** [api/html/d9/dbf/homepage_8php.html [47]](https://github.com/Bearsampp/sandbox/pull/52/files#diff-3e4e78cd2ca7ed43628b1b109628c3feda794c12f3af40652b13e74afcc9f313R47-R47) ```diff - 2024.7.8
+ July 8, 2024
```
- [ ] **Apply this suggestion**
Suggestion importance[1-10]: 6Why: The suggestion improves readability and accessibility by using a more human-readable date format, though it is a minor enhancement. | 6 | |
โ
Replace non-semantic with for better accessibility and SEO
___
**Use semantic HTML5 elements to improve accessibility and SEO. Replace non-semantic
| 6 | |
Performance |
Remove unused scripts to enhance page load performance___ **Ensure that the scriptdoxygen-awesome-darkmode-toggle.js is necessary and used within the page. If it's not required, consider removing it to reduce page load time and improve performance.** [api/html/d9/dbf/homepage_8php.html [22]](https://github.com/Bearsampp/sandbox/pull/52/files#diff-3e4e78cd2ca7ed43628b1b109628c3feda794c12f3af40652b13e74afcc9f313R22-R22) ```diff - + ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: The suggestion is valid as it aims to improve page load performance by removing potentially unused scripts, but it requires verification to ensure the script is indeed unnecessary. | 7 |
Move inline JavaScript to an external file to improve maintainability and page performance___ **Replace the inline JavaScript code with external JavaScript files to improve pageloading speed and maintainability. Inline scripts can block page rendering and are harder to maintain compared to external scripts.** [api/html/d7/dcf/classQuickPick.html [23-25]](https://github.com/Bearsampp/sandbox/pull/52/files#diff-14f4d9b2d0309e6c912ace821d145def986152d764edde6aabd6c73ee5f4b193R23-R25) ```diff - + ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: Moving inline JavaScript to an external file can improve maintainability and page loading speed, although the impact may be minor for small scripts. | 7 |
Closing PR as per @N6REJ .
To test: pull branch add DownloadId = "" to bearsampp.conf below "scriptsTimeout" open localhost, you should see a box saying to subscribe in the header disable your internet and refresh localhost you should see a notice that you have no internet renable your net and go to your account on bearsampp and get your "download_id" from the "My Account" menu. add that to your bearsampp.conf where "DownloadId = "" is. reload localhost. You should see a select box with dropdown and versions when you click on the module name. choose a binary like php, and click a version number.
you should get a message box showings it being installed and that you need to "reload" in a modal when completed.
After succesful install localhost should reload automatically. install an app like phpmyadmin, you should get a modal telling you to edit bearsampp.conf then reload to activate the module do the same for a tool like composer. The same modal should appear. delete "/core/resources/quickpick-releases.json" and refresh local host. Check /core/resources/quickpick-release.json" and verify its been replaced.
check localhost to see that selector is still showing and functional.