Closed N6REJ closed 2 months ago
β±οΈ Estimated effort to review: 2 π΅π΅βͺβͺβͺ |
π§ͺ No relevant tests |
π No security concerns identified |
β‘ Key issues to review Potential Bug The removal of Python CP might cause issues if other parts of the system still rely on it. Ensure all references to Python CP are removed throughout the codebase. User Experience Removal of Python CP menu item might affect user experience. Consider adding a notice or updating documentation to inform users about this change. |
Category | Suggestion | Score |
Best practice |
Use specific exception types for better error handling___ **Consider using a more specific exception type instead of the genericException when throwing errors. This can help with error handling and debugging.** [core/classes/tools/class.tool.python.php [69-77]](https://github.com/Bearsampp/sandbox/pull/87/files#diff-1413001690c9eebd9d6d210081327b0d845509e9fa01b3611d76653bcbecce6bR69-R77) ```diff if (!is_file($this->bearsamppConf)) { - Util::logError(sprintf($bearsamppLang->getValue(Lang::ERROR_CONF_NOT_FOUND), $this->name . ' ' . $this->version, $this->bearsamppConf)); + throw new FileNotFoundException(sprintf($bearsamppLang->getValue(Lang::ERROR_CONF_NOT_FOUND), $this->name . ' ' . $this->version, $this->bearsamppConf)); } if (!is_file($this->exe)) { - Util::logError(sprintf($bearsamppLang->getValue(Lang::ERROR_EXE_NOT_FOUND), $this->name . ' ' . $this->version, $this->exe)); + throw new FileNotFoundException(sprintf($bearsamppLang->getValue(Lang::ERROR_EXE_NOT_FOUND), $this->name . ' ' . $this->version, $this->exe)); } if (!is_file($this->idleExe)) { - Util::logError(sprintf($bearsamppLang->getValue(Lang::ERROR_EXE_NOT_FOUND), $this->name . ' ' . $this->version, $this->idleExe)); + throw new FileNotFoundException(sprintf($bearsamppLang->getValue(Lang::ERROR_EXE_NOT_FOUND), $this->name . ' ' . $this->version, $this->idleExe)); } ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: Using specific exception types enhances error handling and debugging, making the code more robust and easier to maintain. This is a significant improvement over using generic exceptions. | 8 |
Use a constant for the 'IDLE' string to improve code maintainability___ **Consider using a constant for the 'IDLE' string to improve maintainability andreduce the risk of typos.** [core/classes/tpls/app/class.tpl.app.python.php [57-61]](https://github.com/Bearsampp/sandbox/pull/87/files#diff-eba53033bb4f754078cbb62b047d295c301d40e3d7ee6f4e2a5ed479445ceb1dR57-R61) ```diff +const PYTHON_IDLE = 'IDLE'; + $resultItems .= TplAestan::getItemExe( - $bearsamppLang->getValue(Lang::PYTHON) . ' IDLE', + $bearsamppLang->getValue(Lang::PYTHON) . ' ' . self::PYTHON_IDLE, $bearsamppTools->getPython()->getIdleExe(), TplAestan::GLYPH_PYTHON ) . PHP_EOL; ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 6Why: Defining a constant for the 'IDLE' string improves maintainability and reduces the risk of typos, but it is a minor enhancement with limited impact on overall functionality. | 6 | |
Enhancement |
Use a constant array for language keys to improve maintainability___ **Consider updating thegetKeys method to use an array constant for language keys instead of listing them individually. This would make maintenance easier and reduce the chance of errors when adding or removing keys.** [core/classes/class.lang.php [422-432]](https://github.com/Bearsampp/sandbox/pull/87/files#diff-a118643b1351745f98e04a23f3304557badf843a75110c60679c95f023025c38R422-R432) ```diff +private const LANGUAGE_KEYS = [ + self::LOGS, + self::LOGS_VERBOSE, + self::MODULES, + self::NAME, + self::PAYPAL, + self::PYTHON_CONSOLE, + self::PWGEN, + self::QUIT, + self::READ_CHANGELOG, + self::RELOAD, +]; + public static function getKeys() { - return array( - self::LOGS, - self::LOGS_VERBOSE, - self::MODULES, - self::NAME, - self::PAYPAL, - self::PYTHON_CONSOLE, - self::PWGEN, - self::QUIT, - self::READ_CHANGELOG, - self::RELOAD, + return self::LANGUAGE_KEYS; +} ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: This suggestion improves maintainability by centralizing the language keys in a constant array, reducing the risk of errors when adding or removing keys. However, it is not crucial for functionality. | 7 |
π‘ Need additional feedback ? start a PR chat
User description
Removes python control panel
PR Type
enhancement, bug_fix
Description
Changes walkthrough π
10 files
class.lang.php
Remove Python CP constant from language class
core/classes/class.lang.php
PYTHON_CP
constant.getKeys
method to excludePYTHON_CP
.class.tool.python.php
Remove Python CP executable references and methods
core/classes/tools/class.tool.python.php
LOCAL_CFG_CP_EXE
constant and related variable.getCpExe
method.class.tpl.app.python.php
Remove Python CP menu item
core/classes/tpls/app/class.tpl.app.python.php - Removed menu item for Python command prompt.
class.tpl.aestan.php
Remove Python CP glyph constant
core/classes/tpls/class.tpl.aestan.php - Removed `GLYPH_PYTHON_CP` constant.
english.lang
Remove Python CP language entry
core/langs/english.lang - Removed `pythonCp` entry.
french.lang
Remove French Python CP language entry
core/langs/french.lang - Removed `pythonCp` entry.
german.lang
Remove German Python CP language entry
core/langs/german.lang - Removed `pythonCp` entry.
hungarian.lang
Remove Hungarian Python CP language entry
core/langs/hungarian.lang - Removed `pythonCp` entry.
spanish.lang
Remove Spanish Python CP language entry
core/langs/spanish.lang - Removed `pythonCp` entry.
swedish.lang
Remove Swedish Python CP language entry
core/langs/swedish.lang - Removed `pythonCp` entry.