Dash-Industry-Forum / MPEG

Collects issues that need to be reported to MPEG
1 stars 0 forks source link

CMAF: Fix CMAF Presentation Duration #13

Open haudiobe opened 4 years ago

haudiobe commented 4 years ago

Clause 6.6.8 is silent about the duration of CMAF Presentation, but in clause 7.3.6 the definition is provided as an ill formulated requirement: "The duration of a CMAF presentation shall be the duration of its longest CMAF track". It better said that the duration of a CMAF presentation is the duration of its longest CMAF track as a definition. Even that is unclear as it does not clarify what this means. Starting from the presentation time offset?

For the mapping to DASH, the video track is assumed to be the master and hence, the Period duration is determined by the duration of the CMAF video track.

We believe that the CMAF Presentation duration should be a definition and that the definition should be changed to aligned with the duration of the video track.

haudiobe commented 4 years ago

(2020/04/15) Agreed to add