ESCOMP / CTSM

Community Terrestrial Systems Model (includes the Community Land Model of CESM)
http://www.cesm.ucar.edu/models/cesm2.0/land/
Other
305 stars 307 forks source link

intrinsic water use efficiency diagnostic #1245

Closed djk2120 closed 3 years ago

djk2120 commented 3 years ago

We would like to add intrinsic water use efficiency (iWUE) as a history field.

You can compute iWUE from half hourly data with standard output: iWUE = FPSN / (1e-6(GSSUN LAISUN+GSSHA * LAISHA))

However, the monthly mean of iWUE, is not equivalent to calculating iWUE using monthly mean FPSN,GSSUN,LAISUN, etc. Therefore we would like to add iWUE as a diagnostic variable, such that daily and monthly means will accurately capture iWUE.

wwieder commented 3 years ago

Is there also talk of calculating this from VPD (e.g. FPSN*VPD/ET)?

djk2120 commented 3 years ago

Yes. We can also include that slightly different metric. I would suggest

cf1 = 121e-6 ! umolCO2 -> gC cf2 = 1e-2 ! Pa -> hPa iWUE_VPD = cf1 FPSN cf2 VPD / QVEGT

in order to match the units of Keenan et al 2013

djk2120 commented 3 years ago

We have settled on just one diagnostic, IWUELN (intrinsic water use efficiency near local noon) calculated as: IWUELN = FPSN / (1e-6(GSSUN LAISUN+GSSHA * LAISHA)) the units are umolCO2/molH2O

We opted to subset the timesteps within 1hour of local noon (IWUELN), to give a better comparison to observations. Gridcell output of IWUELN may be difficult to interpret (especially in BGC mode) due to land cover change. We would suggest analyzing IWUELN at the pft level.

We decided against adding WUEei, as it was too difficult to generalize given various approaches to data filtering. Instead we would suggest to calculate it from half-hourly model output using the relevant photosynthesis and transpiration (or ET) variables and the new VPD_2M variable.