search

EdwardPiwowar / BBA

1 stars 0 forks source link

4N is not the right bid here #458

Open ThorvaldAagaard opened 5 months ago

ThorvaldAagaard commented 5 months ago

65243C42EAC744E1F09157A4CB78 image

Here it goes OK, but the problem is that BEN checks if 4H or 4N is the best bid, and this is making it difficult to invite partner into the evaluation of slam possibilities

So 12-14 can bid 4H 15-17 makes a slam invite (over 4th suit) 18+ blast into RKC

With a good hand here South would cooperate

I think I have reported the problem with 4th suit before, as this is slammish, and not 10-11 HCP image

So this bidding is expected 1C-1D 1H-1S 3C-3H 4C-4N 5H-6H

1S= 4th SF 3H Slammish 4C= CUE, denying a spade cue 4N= RKC with Hearts

EdwardPiwowar commented 5 months ago

The 4SF implementation is without support. I didn't find a description containing support.

ThorvaldAagaard commented 5 months ago

GIB manage it fine image

The description is also pretty simple.

When using 4SF, any new bid by the hand that use 4SF below game is stronger than bidding game

I think it was one of the thinks I learned about 4SF 40 years ago :-)