EnvironmentOntology / envo

A community-driven ontology for the representation of environments
http://www.environmentontology.org
Creative Commons Zero v1.0 Universal
132 stars 51 forks source link

New classes: soil layer, soil layer top, soil layer top depth, soil layer bottom, soil layer bottom depth #388

Open celineaubert opened 7 years ago

celineaubert commented 7 years ago

soil layer

soil layer bottom

KrishnaTO commented 2 years ago

soil layer was previously added

Remaining 4 need to be added

dr-shorthair commented 2 years ago
  1. A soil horizon is a sub-class of soil layer, which is formed by a consistent genetic process or has a homogeneous composition - the ASLS says "with morphological properties different from layers below and above it".

The formal definition of soil horizon (sub-class of layer with differentia 'composed primarily of some soil') is actually OK for soil layer. However, the textual definition ("A layer which is parallel to the soil surface and which has roughly homogenous physical, chemical and biological properties relative to the soil layers above or beneath it. ") does better match soil horizon. Soil Layer is a more generic thing: some soil-layers are defined purely as a depth range, so are not necessarily homogeneous in their physical, chemical and biological properties.

  1. New class required: Soil Contact - the interface between two horizons. A soil-layer-top of a soil-horizon, which is also a soil-layer-bottom with respect to an adjacent soil-horizon is called a Contact.

OK @meganrwong @ljgregory @abhritchie ?

abhritchie commented 2 years ago

Yes, this definition of soil layer suggests a horizon (horizons can be sub-typed, e.g. NZ: morphological horizon and functional horizon). Our experience is that soil layer is used to describe sampling artifacts whose extent is dictated by the sampling strategy, not the characteristics of the soil. The value of a soil layer class is debatable given ontologies like SOSA can carry the necessary information.

The value of soil layer top and soil layer bottom is unclear.

abhritchie commented 2 years ago

Agree with the need for soil contact. Horizon boundaries have their own characteristics (shape, distinctness).

Suggest soil horizon boundary instead of soil contact.

Contact implies the boundary between mappable soil units. Also, soil scientists may also accuse us of Geology.