Sketch Layer with SceneView

[tomrussell]

I'm having trouble working with Sketch layers when using a SceneView container, when the SketchViewModel is initialised in my useEffect hook I get an error saying that it expects the property of view to be of type MapView

I can work with a 2D view layer instead, which is initialising/ functioning correctly, but I've seen in the JS API documentation that Sketch should be compatible (with some limitations) to a Scene layer as well. Does anyone have any idea what could be wrong here?

  useEffect(() => {
    loadModules(['esri/widgets/Sketch/SketchViewModel']).then(([SketchViewModel]) => {
      if (!sketch && graphicsLayer) {
        setSketch(new SketchViewModel({ view, layer: graphicsLayer }));
      }
    });
  }, [graphicsLayer]);

[tomwayson]

Have you tried what you are trying to do outside of React, like in a JS Bin w/ just the ArcGIS API for JavaScript?

[tomrussell]

Yes I have, changing the MapView in this code sample to a SceneView is working how I’d expect

https://developers.arcgis.com/javascript/latest/sample-code/sketch-geometries/index.html

[tomwayson]

Is the version of the ArcGIS API are you using the same as in the JS Bin from the above sample?

Another thing to try would be to create a CodeSandbox w/ React and just esri-loader that does what you are trying to do.

Please provide the versions of all relevant libraries used and links to any JS Bins or CodeSandboxes you create.

[tomrussell]

Think I've found a likely cause for the issue here, I'm loading the Map/ Scene containers with @esri/react-arcgis@4.0.0 which is internally using esri-loader@2.6.0. All other modules in my app are loaded using my own import of esri-loader@2.10.1, which I can see will request 4.12.0 modules from ArcGIS API

I haven't checked through the release notes for the API but perhaps SceneView support for Sketch was added in recent versions - does this sound about right to you?

Is this what you're trying to address with #114 ? Can you suggest a workaround until this is implemented?

[tomwayson]

I don't think you'll have to wait long @tomrussell, once #134 #135 is approved, I'll merge and cut a v5 release for you to try. Your input is welcome on that PR.

[rpatelcode]

Yes I have, changing the MapView in this code sample to a SceneView is working how I’d expect

https://developers.arcgis.com/javascript/latest/sample-code/sketch-geometries/index.html

Can you please share this Sketch react component code I need it.

[tomwayson]

@tomrussell your issue should be fixed as of v.5.0.0

[tomrussell]

Looks great @tomwayson - works a treat, thanks for the effort on putting this together

@rpatelcode this should give you some guidance on where to start - https://codesandbox.io/s/damp-wood-bnzk6

The components I've written were made following the example on the readme - if you're comfortable working with the hooks API you can get pretty far with this method

[rpatelcode]

Here is the component I tried to make it works https://codesandbox.io/s/sketch-map-srsr6 still struggling how to include screenshot like this https://developers.arcgis.com/javascript/latest/sample-code/sceneview-screenshot/index.html

[tomwayson]

@rpatelcode are you experiencing a bug w/ react-arcgis?

[rpatelcode]

NO, it's not a bug, probably don't know how to make it works

[tomwayson]

then I suggest you go open a question on GeoNet