Foggalong / edinburgh-math-latex

LaTeX templates for the University of Edinburgh's School of Mathematics
LaTeX Project Public License v1.3c
8 stars 3 forks source link

updates margins for twoside #20

Open PatrickKinnear opened 1 month ago

PatrickKinnear commented 1 month ago

Type of changes

Background on the changes:

When creating a report with the twoside option, it is prepared to be printed two-sided and bound as a book. The standard for book binding is for odd pages to come on the right of a two-page spread, even pages on the left. Looking at a two-page spread, there should be three strips of vertical white space: a left margin on the left (even) page, a central margin, and a right margin on the right (odd) page. Ideally all three strips should be of a similar size.

The central margin is made up of the inner margins of the two pages of the spread. As such, the inner margin of each page should be about half the size of the outer margin. This requires a different convention for left/right margins on odd vs even pages.

The previous version placed a narrow margin at the outside of each page and a wide margin on the inside, resulting in a very unbalanced page layout. It's possible that the authors imagined a layout with odd pages on the left, which is the opposite of the standard convention. It's also possible they imagined the wider central margin accounted for binding space, but this should be set using the bindingoffset parameter of the geometry package.

Detail on changes:

The parameters responsible for the twoside page layout are oddsidemargin and evensidemargin. By interchanging these, we obtain a layout that conforms to widely accepted publishing conventions. Even after interchanging, the central margin is slightly wider than the outer margins, which should account for the small amount of paper that would be taken up by the types of bindings (glue binding) typical of a UoE thesis.

Previously there was a manual correction to the maketitle command to ensure the title page is centred. This has been adjusted so that even after the above changes the title page is still centred.

Foggalong commented 4 weeks ago

@PatrickKinnear This is excellent! I printed of a draft of my thesis for the first time last week and it came out with backward binding, so it had been on my to-do list to work out exactly what went wrong here.

Will do a proper review with some test documents I have later b/c I know there's a related issue where with some classes the margins switch sides between the preamble and main chapter content, and guessing that comes from this same spot. Thanks so much :smile: