FoodOntology / joint-food-ontology-wg

This is a repository for documents and issues related to the development of interoperable food related ontologies.
22 stars 3 forks source link

NTR: "organism food management process" #8

Closed ddooley closed 1 year ago

ddooley commented 4 years ago

Looking for a parent term that digestion process and fasting process could be parts of, and work in tandem. It would involve an organism's whole food maintenance process - including the processes that give rise to hunger, or other food ingestion triggers, as well as mastication, digestion etc.

label: food management process definition: The process an organism has which achieves a dietary pattern and involves food location, selection and episodic consumption.

maweber-bia commented 4 years ago

Think it is great to have this general parent term to group all the physiological processes linked to nutrition, including the neuro-regulation process. But I don't catch the meaning of "food location" in the definition. The definition should specify that the scope involves the whole food maintenance process as stated in your comment @ddooley

ddooley commented 4 years ago

For food location - I meant the location of food, i.e. availability - having to source it and obtain it. This was to link to the concept of "food deserts" that I've seen as a research topic. People may want nutritious food but its actually hard to obtain, leading to negative health consequences.

FrancescoVit commented 4 years ago

For food location - I meant the location of food, i.e. availability - having to source it and obtain it. This was to link to the concept of "food deserts" that I've seen as a research topic. People may want nutritious food but its actually hard to obtain, leading to negative health consequences.

Really nice concept. If "location" is not clear, maybe going more directly to the point as you described with simply the wording "food availability"?

label: food management process definition: The process an organism has which achieves a dietary pattern and involves food location, selection and episodic consumption.

If personal preferences, personal tastes, daily routine linked to choices in food (i.e. workload and eating a fresh-cut/convenience food; hoping that I picked up the correct translation), or similar concepts fall in this category, I would say that it could be the reverse. The "food management process" has as a result the dietary pattern. The ONS "dietary pattern" is actually am information content entity, so it should be right to have a process with this entity as output.

In other words, during "food management process" choices about food happen, depending on multiple reasons, which are then concretized in a "dietary pattern", ultimately determining the "diet" (or correlated classes).

ddooley commented 4 years ago

Yes, I agree with all you've said!

ddooley commented 4 years ago

So definition: The process an organism has which achieves a dietary pattern and involves food availability, physiological or psychological motivation, selection, episodic consumption, and digestion.

maweber-bia commented 4 years ago

agreed!

laurenechan commented 4 years ago

@ddooley I think I am a little unclear as to why digestion is involved in this term. Are you implying the physical capacity to consume and digest particular food types impacting food selection etc?

ddooley commented 4 years ago

Yes. Say digestion process was faulty/diseased, then an organism's food management process might involve changing diet, or consuming more, etc.

ddooley commented 3 years ago

@FrancescoVit is this term finalized in ONS now?

FrancescoVit commented 3 years ago

No, lost this discussion. I'll self assign and open issue in ONS repo

ddooley commented 1 year ago

Completed March 21 2021!