FrSkyRC / ETHOS-Feedback-Community

Feedback & suggestions are welcomed here for ETHOS by FrSky
192 stars 87 forks source link

User's demand for servo balance function #2790

Closed FrSky-GX closed 2 months ago

FrSky-GX commented 1 year ago

Some users need to use multiple servos to drive the same side, where the mechanical differences between the servos require similar functions to adjust.

Dsrenger commented 2 months ago

As far as I can test on the simulator (without real model) this looks so fuc.... good

MikePhillyFlyers commented 2 months ago

Hi Bertrand,

Just wanted to pass this by you, in case this would help in your design of the balance function (and even other servo setup funcs as well), I've been a user of Graupner radios for years now (MZ32), they have a very nice balance function similar to what you are designing now. (see the video below, balance starts at about 2:00 in)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ALxShjOS73A

Notice they also have a setup that allows many points on the graph, and you can add more as you wish... if you ever need me to run any functions on my MZ32 or capture some vids for you, I'd be glad to help.

Also, notice the other menus especially their servo limits, endpoints, etc and how they set it all up in the GUIs, etc..

robertobrazill commented 2 months ago

Hi Bertrand,

Just wanted to pass this by you, in case this would help in your design of the balance function (and even other servo setup funcs as well), I've been a user of Graupner radios for years now (MZ32), they have a very nice balance function similar to what you are designing now. (see the video below, balance starts at about 2:00 in)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ALxShjOS73A

Notice they also have a setup that allows many points on the graph, and you can add more as you wish... if you ever need me to run any functions on my MZ32 or capture some vids for you, I'd be glad to help.

Also, notice the other menus especially their servo limits, endpoints, etc and how they set it all up in the GUIs, etc

Awesome!

jasalca commented 2 months ago

I see that the main idea is going very very well. I would like if it is possible for you value for visibility issues on the flying filed in full sun, that the position bar of the stick instead of being white is highlight colour. What it looks like in the "mixer menu" 3a 2a 1a

jasalca commented 2 months ago

I send you an example of visibility aa1 aa2

In the second photo you can see that depending on the position of the stick, being of another color , is better seen according to situations

jasalca commented 2 months ago

With the lastest update of the simulator an hour ago, it is doing very strange things. If I try to raise the engine stick it does not correspond to the output of the channel and in the graph what is supposed to be the stick changes color orange- white- orange. Ethos Simulator 2024-09-16 19-58-39.zip

jasalca commented 2 months ago

I have checked other channels ( elevator, aileron, rudder, ) and the outputs graphics are also malfunctioning

bsongis-frsky commented 2 months ago

The new simulator has a fix for that, it's coming soon

robertobrazill commented 2 months ago

Can you send me the link to the simulator?

bsongis-frsky commented 2 months ago

Available in 1.5.16 nightlies

bsongis-frsky commented 2 months ago

Latest screenshots

image

robertobrazill commented 1 month ago

@bsongis

As an update suggestion, it would be interesting if the point we blocked (locked) could be included as a new curve point, just like in Jeti. I don't know if I managed to make myself understood.