FredHutch / Oncoscape

a web application to apply/develop analysis tools for Molecular and Clinical data
https://oncoscape.sttrcancer.org
MIT License
178 stars 45 forks source link

Java instead of R #242

Open sethfri opened 8 years ago

sethfri commented 8 years ago

For the backend, have you guys considered moving over to a language like Java instead of R? Especially since you're already refactoring the backend, it seems to make sense to switch to a much higher performance language like Java.

Additionally, most developers work in Java, C++, Ruby, etc. If you're trying to attract engineers to improve your project, R doesn't make a lot of sense.

mzager commented 8 years ago

@sethfri The decision to use R for the data processing was driven by the large number of available computational biology libraries. Recently we moved away from using R as the primary web interface and in the Development branch there is now a NodeJS proxy, web and proxy servers. We are very much interested in supporting additional backend programming languages and intend to use Node's ability to import C++ modules and/or Sockets to accomplish this. It would be great to know what language you favor and work together to get make it accessible in Oncoscape.

GalaticStryder commented 8 years ago

The only point I see on Java usage would be compiling Oncoscapse as a universal framework for JVM instead of an analysis website frontend. In any case, there's a project that can handle R and Java coexistence: https://github.com/s-u/rJava I haven't tested it myself (I have no knowledge in R) but may worth if we ever need to extend Onco.

igordcsouza commented 7 years ago

Maybe later, we can think about change the structure of backend to microservices. That way we can choose the better language to each problem. If someone wants to help us programing in haskell or goLang will be possible.

LisaMc commented 7 years ago

@igordcsouza - agreed, we want to use the best tool for the given problem/question at hand. Is there a particular application you had in mind for using haskell or goLang?

igordcsouza commented 7 years ago

Not really, was just a example. I'm new in the project, for now i just am reading the docs and trying to understand how the things really works. Maybe in a couple weeks i can do some contribution bigger than simple docs corretion. :)