IndEcol / RECC-ODYM

The RECC model
MIT License
21 stars 10 forks source link

Missing new materials in the classification #69

Closed CarrerF closed 9 months ago

CarrerF commented 10 months ago

@stefanpauliuk I am not sure if the classification master on Dropbox is the one you used for producing the latest set of results, but we noted that there is a mismatch for some new materials.

Glass and Insulation are listed in Material_Production_i2, but not in Engineering_Materials_m2. We have already collected data in 4_PE_ProcessExtensions_Materials and in 4_EI_ProcessEnergyIntensity, and linked materials to processes in 4_SHA_MaterialsTechnologyShare, so they would be ready to be used.

On the contrary, Bricks are listed in Engineering_Materials_m2, but not in Material_Production_i2, so they are in the stock but do not have any production impact. Data in 4_PE_ProcessExtensions_Materials, 4_EI_ProcessEnergyIntensity and 4_SHA_MaterialsTechnologyShare are also missing.

New non-residential archetypes have non-zero brick intensity, so their contribution is missing.

Also, if I remember correctly, residential archetypes (and maybe non-res too) had some glass and insulation, which were aggregated to Other materials. There is room for refinement here, assigning them in BuildME to their corresponding material class.

stefanpauliuk commented 10 months ago

Hi @CarrerF Indeed, these materials haven't been considered so far.

I propose to add the following (see curent Master Classification file):

add to Engineering_Materials_m2: glass insulation material

add to Material_Production_i2: production of bricks from clay

So these can now be selected in the config file and existing data can be used! Different type of insulation material (fibre-based, plastic-based, rock wool) can be implemented via their different impacts (MF, GHG, energy consumption in production).

still to be done:

stefanpauliuk commented 10 months ago

Brick production energy use and material footprint is now included in \Dropbox\RECC_v2_5_v2_6\data\CURRENT_V2_5\ 4_EI_ProcessEnergyIntensity_V3.2 4_PE_ProcessExtensions_Materials_V1.2 See also the updated master classification as described above: RECC_Classifications_Master_V2.0

CarrerF commented 10 months ago

Thanks Stefan! @LolaRousseau might be useful for you as well

LolaRousseau commented 10 months ago

Great, thanks @stefanpauliuk and @CarrerF! I plan to include the materials in the version of ODYM-RECC that I have, very nice to have the updated files to look at :)