LNP-BP / LNPBPs

LNP/BP standards for bitcoin layer 2 & 3 protocols
https://standards.lnp-bp.org
202 stars 39 forks source link

LNPBP-2 references to an outdated stage of commitment procedure of LNPBP-1 #105

Closed Sosthene00 closed 3 years ago

Sosthene00 commented 3 years ago

I may have missed something, but I think the commitment procedure of LNPBP-2 might refer to a previous stage of LNPBP-1 at steps 4:

I noticed some typos or little issues, maybe I can directly open a PR to correct those if you're ok with that.

dr-orlovsky commented 3 years ago

Thank you for catching this up, you are welcome to do a PR with all of this fixes.

1) removing (instead of P) 2) fixing references to steps as you described everywhere 3) remove use of LNPBP2 tag (we are not talking about tag variable from LNPBP1)

Sosthene00 commented 3 years ago

Actually I wonder if the whole paragraph still makes sense, since it starts with Runs LNPBP-1 commitment protocol on messagemsg, the selected public keyPand public keyS*with the following modification*, but all those modifications are already described in LNPBP-1:

On further reading I noticed more parts that probably need to be update and/or clarified, I made a PR #106 with all this, it will be easier to discuss there.