The format handler does not seem to be triggered on some systems

[decimad]

Hey, another problem I run into is that the format handler does not seems to be triggered on some systems (in contrast to mine with vscode32@win7 running with vscode64@win10).

On those systems, the debug output with 2.8.3 is:

Debug: extension started Debug: registered formatter Debug: uncrustify installed: true Debug: should uncrustify be installed: false Debug: installers found: none Debug: installer choice: undefined

Yet manually triggering a document format does not trigger the plugin handler on these systems. It triggers them on my system though. Are there any other spots I could check that could interfere with the handler being called?

[LaurentTreguier]

On which system(s) exactly does the format handler run/not run ? The Debug: installers found: none line leaves me puzzled. There should be an installer proposed on Windows, macOS and almost every linux distribution...

[decimad]

Hello, sorry for the delay and thanks for the reply.

The situation on all machines is that we want to use the extension on sources trees handled by the C/C++ Tools.

I have the uncrustify extension format handler working (ie. the handler gets triggered) on vscode64@win7x64. I need to add that on this machine I also have the editorconfig extension installed, maybe there is some interaction possible?

The machines failing the triggering are running vscode64@win10x64. The installers found issue you are mentioning may very well be caused by a firewall/priviledges issue. However I assume inside a running vscode instance such issues do not arise (eg. for trigger calls or the like).

[LaurentTreguier]

This is very strange, considering that it works on VSCode x64 on Windows 10 x64 for me... How is uncrustify installed on the machine ? If the extension doesn't offer any installers then you have to install uncrustify manually and either have the executable in your PATH environment variable, or set the uncrustify.executablePath setting. If uncrustify can't be found then the formatter will silently fail, this is why I suspect it's an uncrustify intallation issue.

[decimad]

Hello, thank you! Would the formatter handler in this case with "uncrustify.debug" on still log it was triggered? Because we're missing this notification on these machines altogether. If not, then I need to doubly and triply verify the paths...

[LaurentTreguier]

It should log the location of the config file, and the command line that's executed, even if the path to uncrustify is wrong. The only scenario I can think of in which the code is formatted without getting the logs, is if another formatter was installed and was used by VSCode instead of uncrustify...