NASA-PDS / operations

Tickets for the PDSEN Operations Team
Other
5 stars 1 forks source link

[lid-request] urn:nasa:pds:context:other_investigation:clps #505

Closed alyssambailey closed 4 months ago

alyssambailey commented 5 months ago

See all PDS4 Bundle LIDs at https://pds-engineering.jpl.nasa.gov/content/bundle-lids.

rchenatjpl commented 5 months ago

Hi, @alyssambailey , I'm bringing in @mnhughes here because CLPS confuses me. Your proposed LID urn:nasa:pds:context:other_investigation:clps is to link all the various CLPS missions together? If so, Madison, is this something you guys have thought about and have a solution for? If not, help! Thanks

alyssambailey commented 5 months ago

Hi @rchenatjpl I have a draft context product xml for this where I connect the CLPS Initiative to the missions under it by their spacecraft using investigation_to_instrument_host ex.

urn:nasa:pds:context:instrument_host:spacecraft.clps_to_2ab_pll investigation_to_instrument_host

I am getting a better description of the CLPS Initiative for this and will send you the draft once I have that. Is this approach okay?

rchenatjpl commented 5 months ago

Wait, I found email between Madison and me a year ago in which it seemed that GEO had ideas on what the context products for the spacecraft would be. Missions too?

If GEO has nothing in mind, I'm not sure which is better: urn:nasa:pds:context:investigation:other_investigation.clps or urn:nasa:pds:context:investigation:mission.clps The guide to context products https://pds.nasa.gov/datastandards/documents/context/PDS4_Context_Products_Guide.v3.pdf says: Other Investigation products typically describe projects that have multiple investigators and/or summarize multiple studies. Mission investigations allow different data and documentation to be tied to a mission. Probably other_investigation. I dunno. I'll go with the groupthink.

mnhughes commented 5 months ago

Hi Richard, yes, I agree that other_investigation makes more sense in this case for CLPS.

rchenatjpl commented 5 months ago

Great. So @alyssambailey or @mnhughes, can either/both of you create a first draft of the context product for other_investigation.clps? Or I can take that shot, especially if you send me as complete a list of proposed LIDs of CLPS spacecraft as you have. Thanks

alyssambailey commented 5 months ago

other_investigation.clps_1.0.xml.txt

Here is a draft! I will have an update to the description once that gets sent to me.

rchenatjpl commented 5 months ago

@mnhughes @alyssambailey Does anyone want to modify Alyssa's context product? I'll ingest it soon. We can always update it later.

alyssambailey commented 5 months ago

@rchenatjpl I am expecting an updated description for it by the end of this week and then I will send you an updated one.

alyssambailey commented 4 months ago

@rchenatjpl I have attached an updated file. I updated the description and the start date. I set the start date to be 1/8/2024 which was the launch date of clps_to_2ab, @mnhughes do you think that makes sense? other_investigation.clps_1.1.xml.txt

rchenatjpl commented 4 months ago

Hi, @alyssambailey, this has been ingested, though I rolled the version back to 1.0 since it's the first time it's been on the EN site. https://pds.nasa.gov/ds-view/pds/viewContext.jsp?identifier=urn:nasa:pds:context:investigation%3Aother_investigation.clps The file itself is near the bottom of https://pds.nasa.gov/data/pds4/context-pds4/investigation/

jordanpadams commented 4 months ago

@rchenatjpl are we good to lose this out?

rchenatjpl commented 4 months ago

yes, I probably should have closed it. Thanks