search

Neural-Systems-at-UIO / VisuAlign

Online manual: https://visualign.readthedocs.io
MIT License
0 stars 1 forks source link

Atlas map version control for QUINT #7

Closed sharoncy closed 2 years ago

sharoncy commented 3 years ago

As far as I'm aware there is no way to trace back the atlas version based on the atlas maps generated with VisuAlign or QuickNII. It's a repeating issue that users generate atlas maps and then try to run Nutil Quantifier with the wrong version of the atlas, which gives incorrect results. This is only detected by the user if they are thorough and check through all the output images and reports. It's happened several times that users are certain that they have used a certain atlas version but on closer investigation by us it turns out they've used something else. There is clearly a need for version control here. Something to discuss at the SW meeting @Tevemadar @leuat

sharoncy commented 3 years ago

The atlas maps from VisuAlign contain version info, the atlas maps from QuickNII do not and it is not possible to implement this. Both the JSON and XML files contain version info. Ideally we should implement support for automatic version recognition in Nutil Quantifier, either from the JSON/XML file or based on the atlas maps. No conclusion made at this point but this should be taken into account in future developments.

Majpuc commented 2 years ago

Can we close this issue? @sharoncy

Majpuc commented 2 years ago

This issue is closed on 10Nov 2021. open a new issue if needed