search

OloOcki / awesome-citygml

The ultimate list of open data semantic 3D city models
https://github.com/OloOcki/awesome-citygml
MIT License
240 stars 30 forks source link

Software list #11

Open OloOcki opened 2 years ago

OloOcki commented 2 years ago

Great initiative from the community to extend the repo by the compatible software list.

What do you think? Shall we tag them with additional info following the idea of the dataset list?

Say:

Tags:

Viewers:

thomashkolbe commented 2 years ago

Good idea. But please differentiate between ‘free‘ software and Open Source software. In the latter case, it would even be good, if the respective license would be named (e.g. GPL V3 or Apache etc.).

thomashkolbe commented 2 years ago

I suggest to also include the supported CityGML versions and encodings (e.g. CityGML 2.0/GML or CityGML 2.0/CityJSON 1.0). If a software supports multiple CityGML versions and encodings all supported combinations should be enumerated explicitly.

benediktschwab commented 2 years ago

Yes, tags would be helpful to the reader for a faster overview. Concerning the open source licenses, I would suggest using the SPDX identifiers (see the awesome-selfhosted list as an example).

Moreover, a brief explanation of the difference between a conceptual model and an encoding in the first paragraph might help beginners to understand this relevant detail.

OloOcki commented 2 years ago

Thank you for your insightful remarks. We should definitely include them while adding an additional information.

OloOcki commented 2 years ago

Please find the initial version of the lists with tags: https://github.com/OloOcki/awesome-citygml/blob/main/software.md

Still, many tags to add, and the brief introduction concerning versions and encodings, mentioned by @b-schwab, needs to be written.

Please do not hesitate to directly refine the markdown text or write remarks in this comment section.