PHI-base / curation

PHI-base curation
0 stars 0 forks source link

PMID: 12612806 Characterization of spontaneous mutants of Magnaporthe grisea expressing stable resistance to the Qo-inhibiting fungicide azoxystrobin #153

Closed MPiovesana closed 3 weeks ago

MPiovesana commented 1 year ago

Curated by @MPiovesana. https://canto.phi-base.org/curs/0f7eed243059bf18

MPiovesana commented 1 year ago

Straightforward paper where authors generate spontaneous laboratory mutants of Magnaporthe grisea resistant to azoxystrobin. Mutants are derived from WT strain 4091-5-8, and mutations on the target gene cytochrome b are identified (G143A and G143S). Authors also compare conidial production (results not shown) and stability of the resistance phenotype by testing the germination of spores derived from necrotic lesions following infection of barley leaves (Table 2). Results relevant for curation (resistance to antifungal) are shown in Table 1. Mutant M-145 (inhibited alternative oxidase) is used as a control.

MPiovesana commented 1 year ago

Uniprot ID: authors provide GenBank accession number for cytb of M. grisea (X87999) which was used to identify Uniprot ID (Q36504).

MPiovesana commented 1 year ago

Genotype creation and annotation: Pathogen genotypes were created by selecting amino acid substitution and expression level Not assayed as follows: cytb(aaG143A) cytb(aaG143S)

A single annotation was created for each genotype based on the chemical resistance phenotype displayed: PHIPO term: resistance to azoxystrobin Evidence code: cell growth assay Conditions: agar plates, standard temperature, 6 days post inoculation, +azoxystrobin

MPiovesana commented 1 year ago

Curation completed pending review.

CuzickA commented 6 months ago

Uniprot ID: authors provide GenBank accession number for cytb of M. grisea (X87999) which was used to identify Uniprot ID (Q36504).

I'm a bit confused with the pathogen species name here.

The UniProt id Q36504 is for Pyricularia grisea (Magnaporthe grisea)

However in NCBITaxon for the WT strain 4091-5-8, the species is Pyricularia oryzae (Magnaporthe oryzae)(https://www.uniprot.org/taxonomy/318829) https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/Taxonomy/Browser/wwwtax.cgi?id=318829 image

rather than this option https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/Taxonomy/Browser/wwwtax.cgi?id=148305 image

CuzickA commented 6 months ago

It may be better to use a UniProt id identified by searching for 'cytb Pyricularia oryzae'. Several non-reviewed entries are available - first entry is 'A0A089QDC9' image

Not changed UniProt yet. Will continue checking session first.

CuzickA commented 6 months ago

pathogen phenotype annotations look fine

CuzickA commented 6 months ago

image

Might need to add new strain to the strain list - unless this strain does not below with the pathogen species here (see above uniprot query)

CuzickA commented 6 months ago

strain name linked to Mo on strain list image

CuzickA commented 6 months ago

This has provided more evidence in favour of changing the uniprot id to cytB Mo

CuzickA commented 6 months ago

image

I have now swapped over the UniProt so that we have the correct species name for cytb. The strain is already available.

I have remade the genotype and transferred the annotations

CuzickA commented 6 months ago

AE alteration in archetype

Info not in Nichola's S file or in Mair et al 2016 (for Mo, several entries for G143A, archetype species is Zymoseptoria tritici)

Need to try FRAST

Magnaporthe oryzae cytb(aaG143A)[Not assayed] cytb(aaG143S)[Not assayed]

CuzickA commented 6 months ago

Using AA FASTA from UniProt entry https://www.uniprot.org/uniprotkb/A0A089QDC9/entry

alignment against cytb Zymoseptoria tritici

image

Magnaporthe oryzae cytb(aaG143A)[Not assayed] 'G143A; CytB; SEPTTR' cytb(aaG143S)[Not assayed] 'G143S; CytB; SEPTTR'

image

CuzickA commented 6 months ago

Next steps

1) check AE alteration in archetype with Nichola

Then session will be ready to approve

CuzickA commented 3 weeks ago

Session approved without Nichola checking AE alteration in archetype.

Closing ticket.