Combinations that are not working as of v0.2.6 (unrelated to Revoke.cash):
MetaMask + Frame (Cannot connect to MM, issue likely on Frame's side)
Tally Ho + Rabby (Nothing works, issue likely on Tally Ho's side - maybe on Rabby's side)
MetaMask + Rabby + Pocket Universe (When switched to MM, no popups, when switched to Rabby, throws error when using sendAsync, issue likely on PU's side)
MetaMask + Tally Ho + Pocket Universe (Nothing works, issue likely on PU's side)
MetaMask + Coinbase Wallet + Pocket Universe (When connected to MM, PU pops up twice, issue on PU's side)
The earlier issues with MM + Rabby have been resolved by Rabby. I updated the OP to document some other borked combinations as well as documentation of which combinations have been tested to work.
Combinations that have been tested and are fully working as of v0.2.6:
Combinations that are not working as of v0.2.6 (unrelated to Revoke.cash):