search

Rikkert-RS / VenusOS-TemperatureService

Temperature and Humidity d-bus services for Victron GX
BSD 3-Clause "New" or "Revised" License
16 stars 8 forks source link

Seems to have issues with VenusOS 3.00 #6

Closed twaldenmeier closed 1 year ago

twaldenmeier commented 1 year ago

Hey, Any idea if this is working with VEnusOS 3.0?

On my VRM Console it does switch beteween the following two screens within a second from this:

image

to this:

image

Is this a v3.00 issue or maybe a setting issue?

Rikkert-RS commented 1 year ago

Hello,

I haven't had time to update my Venus OS to version 3 yet. So I can't test it or reproduce it.

best Regards Rikkert-RS

twaldenmeier commented 1 year ago

Thanks for your quick reply!

I'm using a RPi 3B+

I'm also using the Rpi processor temp from the setuphelper ... not sure if that might cause issues

Rikkert-RS commented 1 year ago

Yes I have now also seen stupid question from me. Another question: How are the sensors connected? Which ones are installed?

Oh yes that often gives problems when Setuphelper packages are installed that interfere with each other.

Which are installed?

twaldenmeier commented 1 year ago

My 1 Wire temp sensor is connected to this board and from the board it connects to the RPi: image

image

Rikkert-RS commented 1 year ago

Ok connection looks ok for me. Pull up resistor is on the extra little Board right? Sensor is DS18B20?

It seems that the Service is restarting again and again.

Is SSH access possible for you? Then we can get more out through the logfile

Rikkert-RS commented 1 year ago

Ah forgot: please post your installed packages from Setuphelper.

twaldenmeier commented 1 year ago

Yes, that's the sensor: https://amzn.to/3P2SsNb

This is what I've installed from setuphelper: image

This is your package: image

Rikkert-RS commented 1 year ago

Oh i think is see the problem.

The problem at the moment is that the GPIO pin 26 collides with the "RpiGpioSetup" You can use this both but only with mods in "RpiGpioSetup" For this have a look at: https://github.com/Rikkert-RS/VenusOS-TemperatureService/issues/5#issuecomment-1556277827

For testing deinstall "RpiGpioSetup" and reboot you device

Rikkert-RS commented 1 year ago

"RpiTemperature" does the same as "VenusOS-TemperatureService" but without DS18B20 sensors. So it is double can also be uninstalled to prevent other problems.

twaldenmeier commented 1 year ago

That make sense! I thought 26 sounded somehow familiar. But since the Relay Board needs to use Pin 26 - do I have the chance to change your package data pin to for example Pin4?

twaldenmeier commented 1 year ago

Maybe something like the "RpiGpioSetup" which gives you the opportunity using a custom file for your specific configuration?

Rikkert-RS commented 1 year ago

Oh yes we can test something I'll build a pack with pin 4 and I'll create a tag for it. need some time for it 30min or so.

Alternatively it would also work if you connect via SSH and change the pin in the Config.txt

Config file is also possible but then you must always have SSH access.

Rikkert-RS commented 1 year ago

For quick test change this from 26 to 4

!! only the marked line not the comment lines !! you can find the file under /u-boot/config.txt

grafik

I use WinSCP for that

twaldenmeier commented 1 year ago

Yes it looks like: image

The naming seems to not apply anymore (in case you had a default) but that's what it looks like with the "RpiGpioSetup" still installed

Rikkert-RS commented 1 year ago

Looks good but i do not quite understand what has been changed now?

I think the best convenience is to build it into the Venus menu. I am working on it but unfortunately it is a bit more time consuming

Rikkert-RS commented 1 year ago

Custom names are persistent if you change the names. They are restored on restart

Or the Name issue is a V3.0 feature ;)

twaldenmeier commented 1 year ago

I did not change anything else - at least I'm not aware of ;-) . I just tried to re-install the package and change to Pin 4 again - even now the custom names are lost ;-)

image

But for now this helps a lot and I understand the dependency ... Will you be able to adjust this to make it a little more customizable?

Rikkert-RS commented 1 year ago

yes as I wrote above it is possible

I think the best convenience is to build it into the Venus menu. I am working on it but unfortunately it is a bit more time consuming

is "RpiTemperature" still installed?

Rikkert-RS commented 1 year ago

Are the custome names also gone if you change the names and then restart?

Wait, I'll take a look at the code

twaldenmeier commented 1 year ago

No, the "RpiTemperature" is not installed anymore.

Before restarting (I did change the names): image

After Restart, looks good: image

Rikkert-RS commented 1 year ago

OK looks good for the moment,

i try to update my venus OS the next days and make the pin configurable in V0.6 You can see this in the setup helper when a new version is available

have a nice evening

Rikkert-RS

twaldenmeier commented 1 year ago

Thank you so much! :-)