SamsidParty / TopNotify

The Ultimate Notification Customization Tool For Windows
https://www.samsidparty.com/software/topnotify
GNU General Public License v3.0
163 stars 7 forks source link

Installation Via Command Line #32

Open robmonte opened 1 month ago

robmonte commented 1 month ago

Have you considered having a chocolately package version for releases? It would be nice instead of relying on Windows Store or coming to Github for the binary.

SamsidParty commented 1 month ago

TopNotify needs to be an MSIX package to work, so even if I added it to Choco then it would still have to be installed from the store.

robmonte commented 1 month ago

Would being a chocolatey package that still installs from the Windows Store enable it to work through automation? In my original request when I mentioned the Store, I was thinking more about the manual nature of installing it through there. However, if it can be automated with chocolatey while still coming from the Windows Store I think people may find that useful.

SamsidParty commented 1 month ago

Oh I see, I thought you were worried about the privacy / Microsoft account troubles of using the MS store. I will look into publishing to Choco/winget when I return from my trip.

aqtoo commented 1 month ago

I'd be interested in scoop too, but I'm unsure of the possibility considering scoops usage of mostly portable apps

SamsidParty commented 1 month ago

I think winget would be the best option considering it's built into windows.

SamsidParty commented 1 month ago

I have chosen winget for its native integration into windows and its support for MSIX files out of the box. I am currently working on submitting TopNotify to the winget repo.

terax6669 commented 2 weeks ago

TopNotify needs to be an MSIX package to work, so even if I added it to Choco then it would still have to be installed from the store.

Can you explain why that is?

SamsidParty commented 2 weeks ago

Actually I was wrong, MSIX packages do not need to be installed from the store

terax6669 commented 2 weeks ago

Ok then let me rephrase my question.

Why does it have to be an MSIX in the first place? Is Microsoft locking access to some system APIs behind the store?

SamsidParty commented 2 weeks ago

Yes exactly, Microsoft is only allowing the notification listener API on MSIX/UWP apps, hence the "Not Packaged" error some people were getting.

terax6669 commented 2 weeks ago

"were"?

image

But the app seems to be working regardless.