Closed Smana closed 2 weeks ago
Here are some key observations to aid the review process:
⏱️ Estimated effort to review: 4 🔵🔵🔵🔵⚪ |
🧪 No relevant tests |
🔒 No security concerns identified |
⚡ Recommended focus areas for review Hardcoded Value The `roleId` in the Vault ClusterIssuer configuration is hardcoded, which might not be ideal for a production environment as it changes each time the platform is recreated. Domain Exposure The gateway configuration exposes the `auth.${domain_name}` to the internet, which could lead to security risks if not properly secured. Staging Issuer The certificate configuration uses the `letsencrypt-staging` issuer, which should be replaced with a production issuer before deployment. External Secret Configuration The ExternalSecret configuration for Headlamp might expose sensitive environment variables if not properly secured. |
Explore these optional code suggestions:
Category | Suggestion | Score |
Best practice |
Improve backup path configuration to ensure unique and traceable backup entries___ **Ensure that the backup path includes a variable or dynamic element to preventoverwriting backups and to maintain a clear backup history.** [security/base/zitadel/sqlinstance.yaml [13]](https://github.com/Smana/cloud-native-ref/pull/551/files#diff-c8f70d2eea287798b1a885c2cfd6ac8fd71de8a681552ae3056e239aec5c3059R13-R13) ```diff -path: "zitadel-20241111" +path: "zitadel-${current_date}" ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: This suggestion is valuable as it promotes best practices for backup management by incorporating dynamic elements into the backup path, thus preventing potential data loss from overwrites. | 7 |
Document the new IAM permission to maintain clarity and compliance___ **Add the newly introduced IAM permission "iam:DeletePolicyVersion" to thedocumentation or the permissions management policy to maintain clarity and compliance.** [terraform/eks/iam.tf [67]](https://github.com/Smana/cloud-native-ref/pull/551/files#diff-a11e2f02c4c990223f6e8c1d83c73528359d055b66e90b599c5362a163be822bR67-R67) ```diff -"iam:DeletePolicyVersion", +"iam:DeletePolicyVersion", # Ensure documentation reflects this permission ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 2Why: Adding a comment for documentation purposes is a minor improvement. It enhances clarity but does not affect the functionality or correctness of the code. | 2 | |
Enhancement |
Automate the
___
**Automate the update of the | 7 |
Possible issue |
Ensure correct formatting and security of the external DNS hostname___ **Ensure that the hostname in theexternal-dns.alpha.kubernetes.io/hostname annotation matches the expected format and does not inadvertently expose internal DNS names due to variable interpolation issues.** [security/base/zitadel/gateway.yaml [13]](https://github.com/Smana/cloud-native-ref/pull/551/files#diff-bd8fc5cfeb250c2bafbd3db4a85e84ab316d7a1fd7b8c5dca36afe3d646a24b9R13-R13) ```diff -external-dns.alpha.kubernetes.io/hostname: "auth.${domain_name}" +external-dns.alpha.kubernetes.io/hostname: "auth.${domain_name}.example.com" ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 6Why: The suggestion correctly identifies a potential security issue with DNS hostname exposure. However, the improved code example does not necessarily reflect a universal fix, as the domain suffix might vary. | 6 |
Ensure the IAM role version is compatible and fully functional with the existing infrastructure___ **Verify the compatibility of the IAM role version "5.48.0" with the existinginfrastructure and ensure it includes all necessary permissions for the EBS CSI driver and Crossplane.** [terraform/eks/iam.tf [4-25]](https://github.com/Smana/cloud-native-ref/pull/551/files#diff-a11e2f02c4c990223f6e8c1d83c73528359d055b66e90b599c5362a163be822bR4-R25) ```diff -version = "5.48.0" +version = " Suggestion importance[1-10]: 3Why: The suggestion to verify compatibility of the IAM role version is valid, but it is a general best practice and not a specific code improvement. The impact is moderate as it ensures compatibility but does not directly alter code functionality. | 3 | |
Security |
Ensure the OIDC configuration in Headlamp HelmRelease is fully integrated with the external secret___ **Confirm that theoidc configuration in the HelmRelease for Headlamp correctly integrates with the external secret and that the secret contains all necessary OIDC parameters.** [tooling/base/headlamp/helmrelease.yaml [20-25]](https://github.com/Smana/cloud-native-ref/pull/551/files#diff-8dbebd8b1123cf1d4fd1439590ce0cc4a607e523832c037c7299744065174c04R20-R25) ```diff oidc: secret: create: false externalSecret: enabled: true name: "headlamp-envvars" + keys: ["client_id", "issuer_url", "client_secret"] ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 5Why: The suggestion is relevant for security and configuration integrity. However, it assumes the presence of specific keys in the external secret without verification, which might not always be applicable. | 5 |
Possible bug |
Validate the OIDC provider configurations to ensure they are correct and functional___ **Validate the structure and data ofvar.cluster_identity_providers to ensure it meets the expected format and contains valid OIDC provider configurations.** [terraform/eks/main.tf [48]](https://github.com/Smana/cloud-native-ref/pull/551/files#diff-417ec24690b4cefab94c36369121105f6a398a3640e69aab37f04c36bd48840dR48-R48) ```diff -cluster_identity_providers = var.cluster_identity_providers +cluster_identity_providers = Suggestion importance[1-10]: 4Why: Validating the structure and data of `var.cluster_identity_providers` is crucial for ensuring the correct configuration of OIDC providers. This suggestion could prevent potential runtime errors, making it a valuable addition. | 4 |
/describe
PR Description updated to latest commit (https://github.com/Smana/cloud-native-ref/commit/883d8df82b09f4aa158495fd8ffe33577055958c)
PR Type
enhancement, configuration changes
Description
Changes walkthrough 📝
1 files
iam.tf
Update IAM module version and permissions
terraform/eks/iam.tf
iam:DeletePolicyVersion
permission tocrossplane_iam
policy.11 files
main.tf
Add cluster identity providers configuration
terraform/eks/main.tf - Added `cluster_identity_providers` variable to EKS module.
variables.tf
Introduce cluster identity providers variable
terraform/eks/variables.tf
cluster_identity_providers
variable for identity providerconfigurations.
helmrelease.yaml
Increase Grafana CPU limit
observability/base/grafana-operator/helmrelease.yaml - Increased CPU limit from 100m to 500m.
vault-clusterissuer.yaml
Update Vault AppRole roleId
security/base/cert-manager/vault-clusterissuer.yaml - Updated `roleId` for Vault AppRole authentication.
certificate.yaml
Update Zitadel certificate configuration
security/base/zitadel/certificate.yaml
commonName
anddnsNames
to useauth.${domain_name}
.letsencrypt-prod
.gateway.yaml
Update Zitadel gateway configuration
security/base/zitadel/gateway.yaml
internet-facing
.auth.${domain_name}
.helmrelease.yaml
Update Zitadel Helm release configuration
security/base/zitadel/helmrelease.yaml
ExternalDomain
toauth.${domain_name}
.network-policy.yaml
Update Zitadel network policy
security/base/zitadel/network-policy.yaml
externalsecret-zitadel-envvars.yaml
Add ExternalSecret for Headlamp environment variables
tooling/base/headlamp/externalsecret-zitadel-envvars.yaml - Added new ExternalSecret for Headlamp environment variables.
helmrelease.yaml
Enable external secret for Headlamp OIDC
tooling/base/headlamp/helmrelease.yaml - Enabled external secret for OIDC configuration.
rbac-admin.yaml
Add ClusterRoleBinding for admin user
tooling/base/headlamp/rbac-admin.yaml - Added ClusterRoleBinding for admin user.
2 files
example-public-gateway.yaml
Add comments and modify annotations in gateway example
infrastructure/base/gapi/example-public-gateway.yaml
external-dns.alpha.kubernetes.io/hostname
annotation.helmrelease-vmsingle.yaml
Add Zitadel authentication configuration comments
observability/base/victoria-metrics-k8s-stack/helmrelease-vmsingle.yaml - Added commented-out configuration for Zitadel authentication.