Update license configuration options for CP4Apps Advanced

[leochr]

Updates to the CP4Apps / WSHE licensing / pricing model would likely require changes to the license related config options (.spec.license.*) provided by WLO.

~Need more details from product management to determine the Operator dev work.~

• [x] Update the description of .spec.license field from License information is required. to The license must be reviewed and accepted before the application can be deployed.

• [x] WLO

• [x] Docs

[leochr]

@malincoln Opened this issue to track the potential work needed for Liberty Operator due to CP4Apps / WSHE license changes. Need more details from product management to determine the Operator dev work.

[leochr]

In a meeting yesterday, there was mention of a requirement to add a different set of license annotations based on the entitlement of Red Hat OpenShift. Need further details to determine what's exactly needed within the Liberty Operator.

[leochr]

Regarding the above item, the WebSphere Liberty documentation doesn't mention license annotations when OpenShift entitlement is involved, so it'll likely need to be updated as well. We can raise an issue for ID/doc once further details are received: https://www.ibm.com/docs/en/was-liberty/base?topic=container-tracking-liberty-license-use-in-kubernetes

[leochr]

Design Discussion and Decision:

Current configuration options:

• accept (checkbox)
• edition (dropdown/enum)
  • IBM WebSphere Application Server (default)
  • IBM WebSphere Application Server Liberty Core
  • IBM WebSphere Application Server Network Deployment
• productEntitlementSource (dropdown/enum)
  • Standalone (default)
  • IBM Cloud Pak for Applications
  • IBM WebSphere Application Server Family Edition
  • IBM WebSphere Hybrid Edition

Updated configuration options:

• accept (checkbox)
• edition (dropdown/enum)
  • IBM WebSphere Application Server (default)
  • IBM WebSphere Application Server Liberty Core
  • IBM WebSphere Application Server Network Deployment
• productEntitlementSource (dropdown/enum)
  • Standalone (default)
  • IBM Cloud Pak for Applications Advanced
  • IBM Cloud Pak for Applications Standard
  • ~IBM Cloud Pak for Applications Limited~
  • IBM WebSphere Hybrid Edition
  • IBM WebSphere Application Server Family Edition
  • IBM Cloud Pak for Applications
  • same as IBM Cloud Pak for Applications Standard
• ~entitledOpenShift / entitledCluster / entitledEnvironment / <suggestions?> (checkbox)~ Not required
  • Node is entitled, not necessarily the entire OpenShift
  • Risk: usage is not reported and becomes a problem during an audit

---

License Annotations

IBM Cloud Pak for Applications Advanced

IBM WebSphere Application Server

cloudpakId: "217562c7767641d982cc6df6bcb5cb87"
cloudpakName: "IBM Cloud Pak for Applications Advanced"
productID: "e7daacc46bbe4e2dacd2af49145a4723"
productName: "IBM WebSphere Application Server"
productMetric: "VIRTUAL_PROCESSOR_CORE"
productChargedContainers: "All"
productCloudpakRatio: "11:2"

IBM WebSphere Application Server Liberty Core

cloudpakId: "217562c7767641d982cc6df6bcb5cb87"
cloudpakName: "IBM Cloud Pak for Applications Advanced"
productID: "87f3487c22f34742a799164f3f3ffa78"
productName: "IBM WebSphere Application Server Liberty Core"
productMetric: "VIRTUAL_PROCESSOR_CORE"
productChargedContainers: "All"
productCloudpakRatio: "11:1"

IBM WebSphere Application Server Network Deployment

cloudpakId: "217562c7767641d982cc6df6bcb5cb87"
cloudpakName: "IBM Cloud Pak for Applications Advanced"
productID: "c6a988d93b0f4d1388200d40ddc84e5b"
productName: "IBM WebSphere Application Server Network Deployment"
productMetric: "VIRTUAL_PROCESSOR_CORE"
productChargedContainers: "All"
productCloudpakRatio: "3:2"

---

IBM Cloud Pak for Applications Standard

IBM WebSphere Application Server

cloudpakId: "4df52d2cdc374ba09f631a650ad2b5bf"
cloudpakName: "IBM Cloud Pak for Applications Standard"
productID: "e7daacc46bbe4e2dacd2af49145a4723"
productName: "IBM WebSphere Application Server"
productMetric: "VIRTUAL_PROCESSOR_CORE"
productChargedContainers: "All"
productCloudpakRatio: "4:1"

IBM WebSphere Application Server Liberty Core

cloudpakId: "4df52d2cdc374ba09f631a650ad2b5bf"
cloudpakName: "IBM Cloud Pak for Applications Standard"
productID: "87f3487c22f34742a799164f3f3ffa78"
productName: "IBM WebSphere Application Server Liberty Core"
productMetric: "VIRTUAL_PROCESSOR_CORE"
productChargedContainers: "All"
productCloudpakRatio: "8:1"

IBM WebSphere Application Server Network Deployment

cloudpakId: "4df52d2cdc374ba09f631a650ad2b5bf"
cloudpakName: "IBM Cloud Pak for Applications Standard"
productID: "c6a988d93b0f4d1388200d40ddc84e5b"
productName: "IBM WebSphere Application Server Network Deployment"
productMetric: "VIRTUAL_PROCESSOR_CORE"
productChargedContainers: "All"
productCloudpakRatio: "1:1"