WoWManiaUK / Redemption

WoW-Mania - Redemption - 3.3.5 PvE Realm
https://wow-mania.com/
52 stars 28 forks source link

[Quest] Betrayal - troll controlling scepter does not work correctly #5813

Closed Tolkinz closed 2 years ago

Tolkinz commented 2 years ago

Links: https://www.wow-mania.com/armory/?quest=12713

What is Happening: When a troll under control is dying, it should be switched a fresh new one but here scepter fails too often. Can't give the number, feels like under 50% rate, probably 33% or 20%, so mission success depends on RNG.

What Should happen: The sceptor provided is supposed to work 100% all the time.

Sorry no screenshot. I was too much frustrated. Play log of [Destrosky] might be helpful.

Rushor commented 2 years ago

Well ofc the troll can die, can you may make a video of the error so we can better understand? Thank you

Tolkinz commented 2 years ago

It is simple. When 1st troll is dying, player needs to switch to next provided troll. And scepter fails to CONTROL that troll, it has 5sec cooldown, that's the moment Drakuru runs to me. There's no 2nd chance. Highway to grave.

So the issue is this : why the scepter fails? is it regarded as weapon and dominated by hit rating? I have never seen a quest-given device fails to work at a very critical moment. I did this 10+ times due to bad randomness.

Rushor commented 2 years ago

Okay now i understand, thanks

Echinaceax commented 2 years ago

i will check this out @Rushor

Ok, a few issues here

quest item https://www.wow-mania.com/armory/?item=39664 Heal pet spell https://www.wow-mania.com/armory/?spell=54136

Screenshot of pet bar controls

image

Heals are cast on me https://i.gyazo.com/c432ab9d64af8d32377ac62ab55f2c07.mp4

Extra note please take a look at this #2309 this is the start of this questline

Tolkinz commented 2 years ago

I see nothing wrong with heal spell cuz Drakuru throws poison crystal and its AoE skill which damages player's HP a lot - I mean really a lot. So player needs heal. Heal skill is correct.

Real issue is the 2nd one.

Lemme explain this a bit.

As soon as Scepter is used and starts channeling, previous troll is already OFF and Drakuru starts to run to player.

Therefore, the trick is to position the boss far from player+next swichable troll, at about 35-40% use the special ability HAMMER shape(stun) to earn a bit extra time, then while he is running, player finish channeling and start attack.

Player is kinda busy when switching cause he needs to click troll, channeling, switch target to drakuru and click attack button, this should be done in less than 3 seconds.

This is a very old quest and wowhead gives tons of tips and tricks, however, among them channeling failure is not an option. It really means retrial. I also did this from the retail version of wotlk. And if retrial continues like 10+ times, we get annoyed.

I DIDN'T say I was being attacked by boss and channeling was interrupted. That's NOT what happened. Instead, what happened was just failure after full channeling, and then Drakuru was a few step behind already ready to swallow me.

Hope this helps.

Tolkinz commented 2 years ago

Oh and one more information.

Previous sceptors for geist and abominations also fails to enslave them. Though it does not give any serious harm, it happens all the time.

Echinaceax commented 2 years ago

heal spell isnt correct @Tolkinz

it isnt meant to heal player

I DIDN'T say I was being attacked by boss and channeling was interrupted. That's NOT what happened.

I know its not what you discribed, but it doesnt work as it should, fix with be done according to the findings from tester

thank you for report @Tolkinz

Tolkinz commented 2 years ago

why it isnt meant for player? boss throws huge aoe poison crystals, 3 ticks and you are dead.

Echinaceax commented 2 years ago

why it isnt meant for player? boss throws huge aoe poison crystals, 3 ticks and you are dead.

image

Tolkinz commented 2 years ago

yes it says : Heals the Troll's CONTROLLER

troll's controller is player.

Echinaceax commented 2 years ago

but its not healing the Troll's CONTROLLER

https://i.gyazo.com/c432ab9d64af8d32377ac62ab55f2c07.mp4

Tolkinz commented 2 years ago

how come you make such conclusion from this tooltip

Tolkinz commented 2 years ago

that player is troll's controller from the vid, and he got heals. I dont get what you are thinking

Echinaceax commented 2 years ago

chatting with team atm so hang fire

Tolkinz commented 2 years ago

alrighty

let's not make this overly complicated. what I see is very simple. if sceptor worked just as it was supposed to, I wouldn't have the need to come here. I spent 2.5hrs for that q, you feel my anger....

Echinaceax commented 2 years ago

correct @Tolkinz timestamp 1:19 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xDa-GLMf7no yes I see that

thanks

Ive remove the heal from my check list

Tolkinz commented 2 years ago

finally we got understanding! thanks!

and from the last vid, I am thinking boss mechanic is different. ye I was thinking why changing was so busy like this.

  1. Drakuru does not chase you, does not hit melee when switching to next troll. Instead he casts shadowbolt(?),, which means we are less busy in retail version (I mean when changing)
  2. drakuru throws that poison crystal all the time but here he throws it only at the beginning. quite nerfed, up to you guyz.

My toons are mostly graduated drakuru so would not need the fixed version but hell yea, its better get fixed.

Echinaceax commented 2 years ago

@Rushor I found a 2009 video but didnt show us what we needed so im using the 2015 for visual reference only ignore quest giver difference 😄 etc...

Rushor commented 2 years ago

Can please someone sum up what to fix now, this chat is too huge :D @Echinaceax @Tolkinz

Echinaceax commented 2 years ago

was trying to minimize the spam for you @Rushor 😄

Throw Blight Crystal https://www.wow-mania.com/armory/?spell=54087

mfranca0009 commented 2 years ago

A lot of problems wrong with this, and it's not just what the OP describes and what Echi has mentioned.

For instance, when you do finish off "Drakuru" to the point where he summons the portal and the lich king walks out:

As such, this whole encounter should be researched and reworked to fix it correctly, and completely.

fvicaria commented 2 years ago

If this can be completed just close it.

Rushor commented 2 years ago

I will add that the scepter will not fail again, that is the most needed fix here

Rushor commented 2 years ago

charm should now always work directly, so the quest can be done a lot better

GMZinius commented 2 years ago

confirmed fixed on PTR , quest item doesnt fail on getting a new blightblood troll. fixed on live on next server update