amitbl / blocktube

YouTube™ content blocker
GNU General Public License v3.0
948 stars 67 forks source link

It no longer hides Shorts #450

Open qdnl opened 2 months ago

qdnl commented 2 months ago

With Block Youtube Shorts videos option being selected, I still can see Shorts on my subscription pages, in video page's right pane and in search results.

dot-tb commented 2 months ago

Shorts reapeared for me too.

pseudoenigma commented 2 months ago

Mixes have come back too. Might be related.

saucecode-kjt commented 2 months ago

Shorts reapeared for me as well

slowbluesmaster commented 2 months ago

Please fix the 'Shorts' issue reported in previous reports!

Raizerkerz commented 2 months ago

Yeah this was the primary reason I use Blocktube, so hope it is able to be resolved soon.

DustinWatts commented 2 months ago

Same issue, shorts are no longer blocked. I tried uninstalling and re-installing but this did not fix my problem.

@dot-tb @saucecode-kjt Could you tell us how you fixed it?

saucecode-kjt commented 2 months ago

Same issue, shorts are no longer blocked. I tried uninstalling and re-installing but this did not fix my problem.

@dot-tb @saucecode-kjt Could you tell us how you fixed it?

I never claimed to have fixed the issue, it's still an issue for me. I hope it gets fixed soon, high priority issue if you ask me.

olekse commented 2 months ago

People said it so I could have just liked but I'm going to make a comment because I want them gone that much, I'm forced to use tape over my screen.

anto687 commented 2 months ago

Shorts are appearing on the homepage, however the blocking function is still working if you SELECT a video - it resolves in youtube.com when clicking on any short

Fwanger commented 2 months ago

I'm hoping that someone can update it. I don't want to have to pick another blocker and re-block all this stuff.

f4grx commented 1 month ago

See #464

slowbluesmaster commented 1 month ago

It saddens me to think this could become abandonware.

Some alternative solutions you may want to have a look at, perhaps even try:

https://old.reddit.com/r/uBlockOrigin/wiki/solutions/youtube#wiki_shorts

https://raw.githubusercontent.com/gijsdev/ublock-hide-yt-shorts/master/list.txt

https://gist.github.com/oliverandrich/e632fff2013357951022ccedbdefd9f5

and finally, 2 versions of a Tampermonkey script, in the comments here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40047338

Be advised that I haven't tried any of these, so YMMV

update

I've added the rules from here: https://raw.githubusercontent.com/gijsdev/ublock-hide-yt-shorts/master/list.txt as a custom rule in uBlock Origin (don't forget to click Update). I can still browse YT, and no more shorts. The layout is preserved, and all looks fine.

Please note that you can easily remove that custom rule, should you find it doesn't work for you. To be safe, I've disabled the BlockTube addon from FF, in case its rules conflict with this new custom uBO rule.

update Oct 22: Having used YT with this script for a few days, I can highly recommend it. YT Shorts have completely disappeared from subscriptions, recommendations, etc.

Hallelujah!