search

arunoda / meteor-up-legacy

Production Quality Meteor Deployments
MIT License
2.26k stars 394 forks source link

Mup version confusion #916

Open pors opened 8 years ago

pors commented 8 years ago

Now that I have troubles deploying my meteor 1.3 apps (see #915) I started looking into and alternative version of mup, it seems we have:

  1. https://github.com/arunoda/meteor-up
  2. https://github.com/arunoda/meteor-up/tree/mupx
  3. https://github.com/kadirahq/meteor-up

I assume that doing npm install mup installs the first version?

Which version is recommended for Meteor 1.3? No production quality needed yet.

Thanks Mark

pors commented 8 years ago

PS Thanks for creating mup!!!! I couldn't live without it :)

MasterJames commented 8 years ago

Moving forward the new kadirahq version is your best bet.

gsabran commented 8 years ago

It would be nice to update the doc:

So: which one is the best stable version? How stable/unstable is the kadirahq version?

MasterJames commented 8 years ago

@madushan1000 I think I noticed it was you that was able to change the mup readme but I agree that the dev branch mupx needs a quick rewording too please and thank you.

I would extend that to maybe mention an expected date for a more official depreciation of these previous versions here. I imagine it will take about a month after Meteor 1.3 is officially released.

madushan1000 commented 8 years ago

The current stable version is Mupx (https://github.com/arunoda/meteor-up/tree/mupx). The current development version is (https://github.com/kadirahq/meteor-up). This mup version is deprecated (https://github.com/arunoda/meteor-up). I'll try to add edits to clarify this issue

gsabran commented 8 years ago

would it make sens to replace aroduna/meteor-up's master branch by mupx ?

madushan1000 commented 8 years ago

@arunoda what do you think?

MasterJames commented 8 years ago

No because it's not ready but is that possible when it is?

MasterJames commented 8 years ago

Sorry I meant to say not until its tested with an official Meteor 1.3 test, would be my only consideration at this point. My apologies if overstepping I'm I suppose too quick to comment but used to helping out here. I'm also thinking about what AWS EFS really means for Apollo lately, but the nearly ready Metror 1.3 version is pretty stable and not expected to change much from the current dev branch?

jowilhnson commented 8 years ago

To further add to the confusion, if you install the kadira mupx version, it will cause attempts to use the original mup to no longer work, as all commands like mup deploy will try to run the kadira mupx, not mup and complain about not having a mup.js file.

You can reverse this by running npm uninstall from within the directory you cloned kadiara mupx into and then reinstalling mup from npm. Just be aware the original mup and kadira mupx cannot coexist.