search

aurelienpierreeng / ansel

A darktable fork minus the bloat plus some design vision.
https://ansel.photos
GNU General Public License v3.0
689 stars 22 forks source link

Bug: Delete Development #351

Closed RyanHarvieStark closed 4 months ago

RyanHarvieStark commented 4 months ago

Code of Conduct

Search previous report

Computer's operating system

Linux

What GPU do you have ?

Nvidia

Ansel version

0.0.0+857~gea7aee827

Type of binary

Pre-built packages provided by the Ansel project (.AppImage, .EXE)

What happened?

Delete development has what I think is confusing behaviour. I'm not sure if this can be classed as a bug but it doesn't seem right.

When using delete development, filmic rgb turns on but also color balance rgb is turned on with settings of basic colorfulness standard. Everything else appears to be removed as far as I can see so far.

Shouldn't delete development take the image back to where it was when you had done no edit. In lighttable the image will have no development icon but will still open with filmic rgb and color balance rgb turned on unlike how it would open the first time.

Does your problem occur with OpenCL enabled ?

I don't know

Does your problem occur with OpenCL disabled ?

I don't know

Previous Ansel version that use to work

No response

Output of ansel -d all

No response

Backtrace

No response

pedrorrodriguez commented 4 months ago

This can be set in the preferences. By default it enables filmic and color balance RGB to have a basic image that is "closer" to an out of camera jpeg. You can choose something else if that doesn't suit you.

Jiyone commented 4 months ago

"Delete development" will remove any edition. So Ansel will acts like you open the image in darkroom for the first time : If there are automatic modules presets and if the option that @pedrorrodriguez mentioned above is on "scene-referred", then modules related to those options will be activated.

RyanHarvieStark commented 4 months ago

I don't see that option in preferences. I looked because Darktable has that. I understand why you would have filmic with the color balance rgb to adjust color on first opening but it doesn't do that. When I first open an image which has not been edited before those are not enabled. I'm fine with that and I understand why you might want it the other way. The issue is that it's inconsistent because when I delete development those two modules are activated.

Jiyone commented 4 months ago

Ah yes sorry, that option has been removed because now there is only one workflow.

RyanHarvieStark commented 4 months ago

I removed the images from Ansel then deleted the xmp files. All seems to be fine now. They open with Filmic and Color Balance activated. I'm not sure what happened but maybe there were xmps in there from Darktable although the images showed no edits.