bcgov / climr

An R package for downscaling monthly climate data for North America
https://bcgov.github.io/climr/
16 stars 6 forks source link

Validate CRU and ClimateNA time series #305

Open cmahony opened 1 month ago

cmahony commented 1 month ago

There are big differences between CRU and ClimateNA time series. we need to provide users with an understanding of the pros, cons, and pitfalls of these two data sources. also, we need to evaluate our optimal approach for calculating the 1961-1990 reference surfaces from the combination of these time series with the 1981-2010 normals, as there are potential artefacts here that would cascade through the rest of climr. CRUvsClimateNA_2Panel Tmin 02

CRU has a more credible pattern of change for temperature; the patchiness of ClimateNA is likely mostly station artefacts. relative credibility of GPCC and ClimateNA are difficult to assess; both products are different though. CRUvsClimateNA_Diffplots

Note that there is a lot of variability in the trends calculated from individual stations. CRUvsClimateNA_BCAB Tmin 02

The differences between CRU and ClimateNA aren't necessarily large relative to natural variability, but they can amount to a difference in the direction of the trend. CRUvsClimateNA_ts Tmin 02

cmahony commented 1 month ago

need to investigate