search

carloscuesta / gitmoji

An emoji guide for your commit messages. 😜
https://gitmoji.dev
MIT License
15.85k stars 806 forks source link

gitmoji-org #350

Closed SnO2WMaN closed 5 years ago

SnO2WMaN commented 5 years ago

hello @carloscuesta and @grissius

As far as I know, there are several packages about gitmoji.

How about transferring these repositories to gitmoji org?

SnO2WMaN commented 5 years ago

I wanted to try it out and made it first. The administrator authority will be transferred over time.

https://github.com/gitmoji-org

carloscuesta commented 5 years ago

I don't know how I feel about the org thing 🤔

There are a ton of projects related with gitmoji and I don't think we need to group them

smolijar commented 5 years ago

I think the idea behind it was to unite the official tooling with the gitmoji repository, for instance to give a message that gitmoji-cli is the official primary utility. Approving an independent project and migrating it to the group would be a way to "grant approval" from Gitmoji author. Another thing is that the project looks more "trustworthy" when goin the extra step of creating an organization, than just being in private space.

The idea makes sense to me, but it's not a big deal. If you detest the idea, or are not convinced about its results or if they seem irrelevant @carloscuesta, feel free to close. Unless @SnO2WMaN can provide arguments I missed.

carloscuesta commented 5 years ago

Let's see if @SnO2WMaN can answer some of my questions before addressing this properly

SnO2WMaN commented 5 years ago

It is correct as @grissius has commented.

I showed the idea of gitmoji preset at #354. This is the first reason I built gitmoji-org unofficially.

Currently, gitmoji presets are managed by lerna in the form of monorepo, but originally we intended to manage them individually in a repository called gitmoji-preset- *. This is because the issue proposals are inconsistent and easy to see.

My claim is that I wanted to be convincing by managing individual contribution guides, RFCs, and websites in separate repositories. Sorry for not answering the questions so much, and in English.

smolijar commented 5 years ago

Though I like the idea of org, I think that introducing decentralized presets is a road to hell, apart from the implementation issues I summarized in #354

SnO2WMaN commented 5 years ago

Currently there is a negative opinion about preset, so for the time being, all repositories in the current gitmoji-org will be transferred to my personal repository. gitmoji-org will be left as it is, so please think again if you feel like it...

smolijar commented 5 years ago

There is just negative opinion from my side about the implementation of the solution. @carloscuesta might have a different opinion.