stacklock2nix

This repository provides a Nix function: stacklock2nix. This function generates a Nixpkgs-compatible Haskell package set from a stack.yaml and stack.yaml.lock file.

stacklock2nix will be most helpful in the following two cases:

• You (or your team) are already using Stack, and you want an easy way to build your project with Nix. You want to avoid the complexities of haskell.nix.

• You are a happy user of the Haskell infrastructure in Nixpkgs, but you want an easy way to generate a Nixpkgs Haskell package set from an arbitrary Stackage resolver.

  At any given time, the main Haskell package set in Nixpkgs only supports a single version of GHC. If you have a complex project that needs an older or newer version of GHC, stacklock2nix can easily generate a package set that is likely to compile.

Quickstart

You can get started with stacklock2nix by either adding this repo as a flake input and applying the exposed .overlay attribute, or just directly importing and applying the ./nix/overlay.nix file. This overlay exposes a top-level stacklock2nix function.

This repo contains two example projects showing how to use stacklock2nix. Both of these projects contain mostly the same Haskell code, but they use different features of stacklock2nix:

• Easy example

  This is an easy example to get started with using stacklock2nix. This method is recommended for people that want to play around with stacklock2nix, or just easily build their Stack-based projects with Nix. All the interesting code is documented in the flake.nix file.

  From the ./my-example-haskell-lib-easy directory, you can build the Haskell app with the command:

  $ nix build

  You can get into a development shell with the command:

  $ nix develop

  From this development shell, you can use cabal to build your project like normal:

  $ cabal build all

  Development tools like haskell-language-server are also available.

• Advanced example

  This is an example that uses more of the advanced features of stacklock2nix. This method is recommended for people that need extra flexibility, or people who also want to use stack for development. The interesting code is spread out between the flake.nix file, and the overlay.nix file.

  Just like the above, you can run nix build to build the application, and nix develop to get into a development shell. From the development shell, you can run cabal commands.

  In addition, you can also use the old-style Nix commands. To build the application:

  $ nix-build

  To get into a development shell:

  $ nix-shell

  You can also use stack to build your application:

  $ stack --nix build

stacklock2nix Arguments and Return Values

The arguments to stacklock2nix and return values are documented in ./nix/build-support/stacklock2nix/default.nix.

Please open an issue or send a PR for anything that is not sufficiently documented.

How to Generate stack.yaml and stack.yaml.lock

If you're not already a Stack user, you'll need to generate a stack.yaml and stack.yaml.lock file for your Haskell project before you can use stacklock2nix.

In order to generate a stack.yaml file, you will need to make stack available and run stack init:

$ nix-shell -p stack --command "stack init"

One unfortunate thing about stack is that if you're on NixOS, stack tries to re-exec itself in a nix-shell with GHC available (run stack --verbose init and look for nix-shell to see exactly what stack is trying to do). stack will try to take GHC from your current Nix channel. However, it is possible that stack will try to use a GHC version that is not available in your current Nix channel.

In order to deal with this, you can force stack to use a NIX_PATH with a different channel available. You should pick a channel (or Nixpkgs commit) that contains the GHC version stack is trying to use. For example, here's a shortcut for forcing stack to use the latest commit from the nixpkgs-unstable channel:

$ nix-shell -p stack --command "stack --nix-path nixpkgs=channel:nixpkgs-unstable init"

Once you have a stack.yaml available, you can generate a stack.yaml.lock file with the following command:

$ nix-shell -p stack --command "stack query"

Note that the --nix-path argument may be necessary here as well.

If you have any problems with Stack, make sure to check the upstream Stack documentation. You may also be interested in Stack's Nix integration.

Nix Cache

Because of how stacklock2nix works, you won't be able to pull any pre-built Haskell packages from the shared NixOS Hydra cache. Its recommended that you use some sort of Nix cache, like Cachix.

This is especially important if you're trying to introduce Nix into a professional setting. Not having to locally build transitive dependencies is a big selling-point for doing Haskell development with Nix.

stacklock2nix vs haskell.nix

If you want to build a Haskell project with Nix using a stack.yaml and stack.yaml.lock file as a single source of truth, your two main choices are stacklock2nix and haskell.nix.

haskell.nix is a much more comprehensive solution, but it also comes with much more complexity. stacklock2nix is effectively just a small wrapper around existing functionality in the Haskell infrastructure in Nixpkgs.

Advantages of haskell.nix:

• The ability to build a Haskell project without a stack.yaml file, just using the Cabal solver to generate a package set.
• The ability to build a project based just on a stack.yaml file (without also requiring a stack.yaml.lock file).
• A shared cache from IOHK. (Although users commonly report not getting cache hits for various reasons.)
• The ability to cross-compile Haskell libraries. (For instance, building an ARM64 binary on an x86_64 machine.)

Advantages of stacklock2nix:

• Integrates with the Haskell infrastructure in Nixpkgs. Easy to use if you're already familiar with Nixpkgs.
• Code is simple and well-documented.
• Unlike haskell.nix, Nix evaluation is very fast (so you don't have to wait 10s of seconds to jump into a development shell).

Versioning

stacklock2nix is versioned by Semantic Versioning. It is recommended you pin to one of the Release versions instead of the main branch. You may also be interested in the CHANGELOG.md file.

Note: stacklock2nix provides a Haskell package set overlay called suggestedOverlay. This overlay contains overrides for various Haskell packages that are necessary for building with Nix. For instance, some Haskell packages have tests that assume it is possible to access the internet. This overlay disables tests for these packages, as well as a bunch of other helpful fixes.

This suggestedOverlay is not part of the Semantic Versioning guaranteed by stacklock2nix. There may be overrides added to or removed from suggestedOverlay without bumping the version of stacklock2nix. (Although, this is unlikely to be much of a problem for most users in practice.)

FAQ

• Are there any other examples of using stacklock2nix?

  Yes, there is a blog series about stacklock2nix that gives a few examples of building actual Haskell projects.

• Is it possible to use stacklock2nix to build a statically-linked Haskell library?

  Recent versions (since mid-2022) of the Haskell infrastructure in Nixpkgs have the ability to link Haskell executables completely statically. An easy way to test this out is to use the pkgsStatic subpackage set in Nixpkgs.

  Instead of passing a value like pkgs.haskell.packages.ghc924 to the baseHaskellPkgSet of the stacklock2nix function, pass pkgs.pkgsStatic.haskell.packages.ghc924:

  final: prev: {
    my-haskell-stacklock = final.stacklock2nix {
      stackYaml = ./stack.yaml;
      baseHaskellPkgSet = final.pkgsStatic.haskell.packages.ghc924;
      callPackage = final.pkgsStatic.callPackage;
      ...
    };
  }

  Here is a fully-worked example of using stacklock2nix to build a statically-linked Pandoc.

• When using stacklock2nix do you ever need to compile GHC?

  In general, no.

  stacklock2nix uses the Haskell infrastructure from Nixpkgs. As long as you're on a standard Nixpkgs Channel, you should be able to pull any available version of GHC from the Nixpkgs/NixOS/Hydra cache. stacklock2nix doesn't override the GHC derivations in any way, so you should almost never have to recompile GHC.

  stacklock2nix does override all the Haskell packages in your Stackage resolver, so you will have to compile all the Haskell packages you use (similar to when you use stack).

• Is there any chance that a Haskell dependency specified in stack.yaml or stack.yaml.lock will become a different version depending on whether I compile directly with stack, or with Nix using stacklock2nix?

  No.

  stacklock2nix reads the stack.yaml.lock file and generates a completely new Nix package for each Haskell dependency specified in your stack.yaml and stack.yaml.lock file. stacklock2nix uses the exact version of each package from the stack.yaml.lock file.

• I'm seeing an error about not being able to find a .json file. What is this?

  When using stacklock2nix, sometimes you'll see an error about not being able to find a PKG.json or PKG.cabal file. Here's an example of what this looks like:

  $ nix build -L
  ...
  all-cabal-hashes-component-happy> cp: cannot stat '/nix/store/bz3lipc0zb8s6cgjvf23mrx7iicgcy8l-source/happy/1.20.1.1/happy.json': No such file or directory

  This is an internal error from haskellPackages.callHackage (which is used by stacklock2nix) saying that your all-cabal-hashes is too old. It is not able to find the package version it is looking for.

  The solution to this is to pass a newer version of all-cabal-hashes to stacklock2nix:

  final: prev: {
    my-haskell-stacklock = final.stacklock2nix {
      stackYaml = ./stack.yaml;
      all-cabal-hashes = final.fetchFromGitHub {
        owner = "commercialhaskell";
        repo = "all-cabal-hashes";
        rev = "9ab160f48cb535719783bc43c0fbf33e6d52fa99";
        sha256 = "sha256-Hz/xaCoxe4cJBH3h/KIfjzsrEyD915YEVEK8HFR7nO4=";
      };
      ...
    };
  }

  You should be able to go to https://github.com/commercialhaskell/all-cabal-hashes/tree/hackage and just pick the latest commit. It is also possible to add this repo as a Nix flake input.

• I'm seeing errors about infinite recursion. What do I do?

  When using stacklock2nix, occasionally you'll get errors about infinite recursion. This looks like the following:

  $ nix build -L
  error: infinite recursion encountered
  
         at /nix/store/rksi78f7vq2xrfghg6jfg1r5dsa8lbv7-source/pkgs/stdenv/generic/make-derivation.nix:314:7:
  ...

  The first step to debugging this is to give the --show-trace flag to nix build:

  $ nix build -L --show-trace
  error: infinite recursion encountered
  
         at /nix/store/rksi78f7vq2xrfghg6jfg1r5dsa8lbv7-source/pkgs/stdenv/generic/make-derivation.nix:314:7:
  
            313|       depsHostHost                = lib.elemAt (lib.elemAt dependencies 1) 0;
            314|       buildInputs                 = lib.elemAt (lib.elemAt dependencies 1) 1;
               |       ^
            315|       depsTargetTarget            = lib.elemAt (lib.elemAt dependencies 2) 0;
  
         … while evaluating the attribute 'buildInputs' of the derivation 'pango-0.13.8.2'
  
         at /nix/store/rksi78f7vq2xrfghg6jfg1r5dsa8lbv7-source/pkgs/stdenv/generic/make-derivation.nix:270:7:
  
            269|     // (lib.optionalAttrs (attrs ? name || (attrs ? pname && attrs ? version)) {
            270|       name =
               |       ^
            271|         let
  
         … while evaluating the attribute 'propagatedBuildInputs' of the derivation 'diagrams-cairo-1.4.2'

  If you squint (and a know a little about Haskell and Nix), you can see that the Haskell package diagrams-cairo likely depends on the Haskell package pango.

  What's going on is that the Haskell package pango depends on the system package pango, and takes the system package pango as one of its build inputs, but it is actually getting passed itself (not the system package pango), which causes the infinite recursion. You can fix this like the following:

  final: prev: {
    my-haskell-stacklock = final.stacklock2nix {
      stackYaml = ./stack.yaml;
      cabal2nixArgsOverrides = args: args // {
        "pango" = verion: { pango = final.pango; };
      };
      ...
    };
  }

  This passes the system library pango (that is, final.pango) as an argument to the Haskell library pango (that is, "pango" in this example).

  This is caused by an unfortunate interaction between cabal2nix and Nixpkgs. See cabal2nixArgsForPkg.nix for a more in-depth explanation of this problem.

• I'm getting an error about the cabal file missing the 'name' field. What do I do?

  If you see an error of this kind:

  ...
  > stacklock2nix: replace Cabal file with revision from /nix/store/l6cda10i5sflwyh1ms0yppx742cszi44-transformers-compat-0.7.2-cabal-file.
  ...
  > Warning: transformers-compat.cabal:0:0: "name" field missing
  > CallStack (from HasCallStack):
  >   withMetadata, called at libraries/Cabal/Cabal/src/Distribution/Simple/Utils.hs:370:14 in Cabal-le.Utils
  > Error: Setup: Failed parsing "./transformers-compat.cabal".
  ...
  

  It could be due to your nix store being inconsistent. Check that the relevant file exists (the one in the store), and then try running the following to debug:

  nix-store --verify --repair --check-contents

Contributions and Where to Get Help

Contributions are highly appreciated. If there is something you would like to add to stacklock2nix, or if you find a bug, please submit an issue or PR!

The easiest way to get help with stacklock2nix is to open an issue describing your problem. If you link to a repository (even a simple example) that can be cloned and demonstrates your problem, it is much easier to help.

Hacking on stacklock2nix

If you're interested in hacking on stacklock2nix, there are two main ways to test the changes you're making:

1. Run the tests in the ./test directory.

   From ./test/, run all tests:

   $ nix-build

   Or, run individual tests. For instance, the new-package-set test:

   $ nix-build ./nixpkgs.nix -A stacklock2nix-tests.new-package-set

2. Try building the two example projects.

   Using the "easy" example, from the ./my-example-haskell-lib-easy/ directory:

   $ nix build

   Using the "advanced" example, from the ./my-example-haskell-lib-advanced/ directory:

   $ nix build

   WARNING: You need to update the stacklock2nix flake input to use the stacklock2nix version from your checked-out stacklock2nix repo. You can do so with a command like:

   $ sed -i -e 's|github:cdepillabout/stacklock2nix/main|path:../.|' flake.nix

Sponsor stacklock2nix

Sponsoring stacklock2nix enables me to spend more time fixing bugs, reviewing PRs, and helping people who run into problems. I prioritize issues and PRs from people who are sponsors.

You can find the sponsor page here.