Logo request: Tekton Results

wlynch commented 1 year ago

cc @adambkaplan (feel free to correct / add any additional details!)

Project Objective

Tekton Results is a Tekton sub-project that aims to help users logically group CI/CD workload history and separate out long term result storage away from the Pipeline controller. This allows you to:

Provide custom Result metadata about your CI/CD workflows not available in the Tekton TaskRun/PipelineRun CRDs (for example: post-run actions)
Group related workloads together (e.g. bundle related TaskRuns and PipelineRuns into a single unit)
Make long-term result history independent of the Pipeline CRD controller, letting you free up etcd resources for Run execution.
Store logs produced by the TaskRuns/PipelineRuns so that completed Runs can be cleaned to save resources.

How the logo would be used, where it will be placed

Primarily on the repo (https://github.com/tektoncd/results) + any external materials (e.g. talks, blogs, etc).

Logo ideas

Would like to stay on-theme with the other sub-project logos https://github.com/cdfoundation/artwork/tree/main/tekton/additional-artwork

"Archives" - e.g. file cabinets, floppy disks, etc.

Deadline / Timelines

None

fdegir commented 1 year ago

Thanks @wlynch.

We submitted an LF Design Request and will get back to you as soon as we get response to the request.

fdegir commented 1 year ago

@wlynch @adambkaplan Here are the concepts for your review.

TektonResults-LogoPresentation-v1.pdf

Please let me know of your feedback.

adambkaplan commented 1 year ago

I started a poll on the Results project to get direct community feedback: https://github.com/tektoncd/results/discussions/451

adambkaplan commented 1 year ago

@fdegir feedback from the community (source):

Concepts A and B combined had the plurality of votes. Consensus is that using "B" as the base (with the file icon in the background) with design elements from A could work. The "circuit board" design elements in B didn't resonate. For reference/inspiration, I used a "cat in file cabinet" image in my cdCon presentation for Results, and that elicited positive reaction from the audience.

Concept E had a large number of votes, but many of the active contributors rejected it in subsequent working group meetings. Concepts C and D had the least votes.

fdegir commented 1 year ago

Thanks @adambkaplan. I passed the community feedback to our team and will get back to you under this issue as soon as I hear back.

fdegir commented 1 year ago

@wlynch @adambkaplan Our team updated the design based on community feedback. Could you please take a look at it in this file and let me know of your feedback?

adambkaplan commented 1 year ago

@fdegir apologies it's taken a while to get back - based on our discussion, this version feels too cluttered an can be simplified. We suggested the following:

The "folder" can be made smaller so only the top is visible.
The two extra lines near the cat's neck can be removed.
Padding around the cat's face doesn't appear to be consistent (especially around the ears).
Remaining icons can be adjusted (and/or removed) to achieve a balanced look and feel.

fdegir commented 1 year ago

Thanks @adambkaplan! I passed the feedback to our team and get back to you once I hear back.

fdegir commented 1 year ago

@adambkaplan Please find the new concept attached and let me know of the feedback from the community.

TektonResults-LogoConcepts-v3.pdf

adambkaplan commented 1 year ago

@fdegir apologies for the delay on this, it was on my queue and slipped through the cracks.

:+1: on v3 of the logo! https://github.com/tektoncd/results/discussions/451#discussioncomment-6627199

fdegir commented 12 months ago

@adambkaplan @wlynch Sent the Tekton Result logos based on v3 via a pull request to artwork repo. Could you please take a look?

cdfoundation / foundation