search

code-charity / youtube

[top~1 open YouTube & Video web-extension] Enrich your experience & choice! 🧰180+ options & clever features📌set+forget📌Longest-standing(yet rare&tough alone. Please help/join🧩us👨‍👩‍👧‍👧) ..⋮ {playback|content discovery|player|extra buttons|distractions|related videos|shorts|ads|quality|codec|full tab|full screen}
http://improvedtube.com
Other
3.31k stars 500 forks source link

Adblock Detection on YouTube #1949

Open pleappleappleap opened 5 months ago

pleappleappleap commented 5 months ago

Bug Report:

⚬ BUG: YouTube adblock detection slows down the site in 2024. ⚬ HOW: Enable the ad blocking then try to use YouTube. Behavior returns to normal after disabling adblock.

ImprovedTube commented 5 months ago

hi! @pleappleappleap a consistent slow-down? tried repeatedly? can you see anything in browser console F12 ?

thanks!

Anoaxx commented 5 months ago

My @ImprovedTube guy.. Its not on our side, its on youtube side. Youtube is fighting ad-blockers with slowing down the bufforing. And its only working if YT detects ENABLED ADBLOCKERS ONLY, not installed. In addition, i can suggest adding option to speed up(to max estension is letting us so 16x) ads and skiping automatically when possible. What do you think? ^^

ImprovedTube commented 5 months ago

hi @Anoaxx, cant be sure if @pleappleappleap noticed a new change /consistent reaction to enabling our ad block feature? - In that case we could change it already. (Many people might have it enabled without it even working. )

speed up

by experience? another extension doing that with muted sound? idk what will be the difference (in YouTube's analysis. they shouldnt bill advertisers for that as much) 16x is the browser max. afaik.

pleappleappleap commented 5 months ago

@ImprovedTube Indeed, this behavior is not specific to your adblock function. Youtube is now exhibiting this behavior with all adblock plugins on Chrome.

pleappleappleap commented 5 months ago

My @ImprovedTube guy.. Its not on our side, its on youtube side. Youtube is fighting ad-blockers with slowing down the bufforing. And its only working if YT detects ENABLED ADBLOCKERS ONLY, not installed. In addition, i can suggest adding option to speed up(to max estension is letting us so 16x) ads and skiping automatically when possible. What do you think? ^^

I don't see the place to configure speeding up only ads. @Anoaxx, could you please point me at that configuration option? That would help while I'm waiting for the adblock support to work.

Anoaxx commented 5 months ago

its an extension for chrome/opera etc but here i was just talking about maybe adding it in a future

raszpl commented 4 months ago

adblocking should be removed from ImproveTube entirely, it only risks extension being deleted by google, and YT is currently fighting adblocks making changes daily so there is no chance keeping up. uBlock does daily updates just to make it work.