Open sivaraam opened 1 year ago
Hey @sivaraam, I want to work on this issue.
Hey I tried reproducing this issue, but it's taking hours to upload a photo and still the photo hasn't been uploaded. Can anyone help me in this regard, I'm new to the project. Or is there a testing account, which has pre-added test photos, that I can use to test the application.
Update on when I tried reproducing issue by editing just the caption,
Update on when I tried reproducing issue by editing just the caption, proofWiki.mp4
So, it shows no description for you in the edit page but then after you submit the description is left intact. Interesting :thinking:
May be try having caption and description for the image in two languages? The image I faced a problem with had caption and description in 2 languages.
@gururani-abhishek Just checking to know if you were able to get any leads regarding this issue ? š
Hey there at @sivaraam I tried recreating this issue myself using the same caption, description, and image you provided, however I did not get the same issue you had.
Do you recall anything else about how you were able to find this bug? Ill do my best to see if I can figure out what's wrong!
@KorelU Excuse the delayed response. I certainly do observe the bug stil. I've added a recording to the description. Kindly check the same.
Also, a few things:
PS: For me, the issue occurs when editing either language description, though
Hello, I would like to try to resolve this issue if possible.
When I tried to upload an image, an error occurred and the upload failed. It seems to be a stack error. I would like to ask if there is any way to solve this problem in the past.
When I tried to upload an image, an error occurred and the upload failed. It seems to be a stack error.
Do you mean you get the mentioned exception for all your uploads ?
I would like to ask if there is any way to solve this problem in the past.
Could you clarify a bit on what you mean by solve the problem in the past ? š¤
@ZIYANGSONG2003 Any progress to share? :-)
Hello, if no one is assigned on this issue I would really like to work on it with @EleniVasilaki if possible.
Hello, if no one is assigned on this issue I would really like to work on it with @EleniVasilaki if possible.
We are really keen to resolve it if feasible
Sure. Could you either confirm that you could reproduce the issue? It would be great if you could post a screen recording.
Hi, @sivaraam the first time we tried we managed to successfully reproduce the issue getting the results shown in the screenshots however we made several other attempts to reproduce it and none of them were successful.
Hi, @sivaraam the first time we tried we managed to successfully reproduce the issue getting the results shown in the screenshots however we made several other attempts to reproduce it and none of them were successful.
This is indeed unfortunate. Could you try reaching out to the on-wiki user who faced the issue to see if you could get a possible set of steps which caused the bug for them?
Summary
The app seems to completely blank the picture's details (description, location, categories) when using the Edit caption feature to edit the caption alone of an uploaded image. An example could be found in the following picture: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Sunset_view_from_Samanar_hills.jpg
When you look at the history, the edits with "Updating Description" completely nuke the media details of the file. If you look closely each such edit is made from the app and is associated with an edit of the caption.
Steps to reproduce
Expected behaviour
Only the caption should be updated.
Actual behaviour
All media details such as description, location, caption are nuked.
Device name
OnePlus Nord
Android version
Android 12
Commons app version
master @ 1649d1e2ce1866d14c3225f07e55ff34123cf7d4
Device logs
No response
Screen-shots
Recording of the issue
https://github.com/commons-app/apps-android-commons/assets/12448084/64055de2-bf94-422d-a3ef-e83af3765970
Would you like to work on the issue?
Prefer not
See also, report of this issue on-wiki