search

cosimoNigro / agnpy_paper

Repository containing scripts to produce the plots in the agnpy paper.
4 stars 2 forks source link

EC on SS disk comparison (Fig 9) - high energy issue #4

Closed jsitarek closed 3 years ago

jsitarek commented 3 years ago

comment from the paper: The red line ends a bit before the reference line in the left figure. I think it might some boundary problem (e.g. the last point being very close to the maximum energy of the electrons). When I modified your fig 9 macro to compute the curve with more fine frequencies , the cutoff got very close to the last point (however the points at the end of the spectrum got somewhat jumpy, possibly due to linear integration in disk radius)

jsitarek commented 3 years ago

here is a version with the top plot computed with finer binning than the reference. it limits considerably the difference in the cutoff place, but it is a bit messy, because the top and bottom plots are computed from different points

figure_9 figure_9_ec_disk_validation.py.gz

cosimoNigro commented 3 years ago

PR #5 should have improved all the EC comparison plots (I played with the number of points in the frequency and Lorentz factors grid), her is what I get now: figure_9 figure_10 figure_11 @jsitarek, better?

jsitarek commented 3 years ago

thx @cosimoNigro, looks indeed much nicer now,