search

dotnet-foundation / project-maturity-model

Proposal/RFC for new .NET library development model.
MIT License
39 stars 8 forks source link

Program clarification #4

Open HurricanKai opened 5 years ago

HurricanKai commented 5 years ago

According to https://devblogs.microsoft.com/dotnet/joining-the-net-foundation-maturity-model-pilot/ there is a "new pilot program" but I can't seem to find what that means? later in that same post "The .Net Foundation is proposing". What actually is happening? Is this "proposal" put into place? part of it? I can't seem to find anything new on https://opensource.microsoft.com/ But part of what's proposed here is already implemented there (for example "Run an ecosystem-wide "up-for-grabs" or "help-wanted" board for projects.", though just in part).

richlander commented 5 years ago

Excellent questions ...

The pilot program is mostly focused on the maturity ladder. That's the part we're starting now. We are starting with a half-dozen projects and are looking for others to express interest. There are no projects officially placed on the ladder at this point. This is the next step.

The other things, like the project board is still coming. That's currently just an idea and not a concrete plan.

The entire proposal is a .NET Foundation not Microsoft initiative. So, the only thing that might show up on a Microsoft site is saying "hey, we're participating" but not defining anyway. This blog post from the .NET Team (from me, actually) is a good example: https://devblogs.microsoft.com/dotnet/joining-the-net-foundation-maturity-model-pilot/

Does that help?

charlesroddie commented 5 years ago

Can open source projects that are currently in a Microsoft-affiliated organization join the maturity model and/or foundation, or is this only for "community" projects?

richlander commented 5 years ago

All individuals and organizations are welcome to participate provided their projects satisfy the characteristics in the maturity model. So, yes, Microsoft is invited to participate.

HurricanKai commented 5 years ago

I see, is there a list of Participating Projects yet (Level 4 / 3 / 2 / 1?) And is there a reason all dotnet/ projects aren't automatically level 3 (4?) I believe all of them meet the requirements, and it would quickstart things, since further levels also require dependencies to be of the same (or higher) level. Ie all Rx dependent projects need Rx to be approved at some point (if they want to be approved themselves)

clairernovotny commented 5 years ago

Right now, there isn't a centralized list of projects at each level, but that's a great idea. We'll need an underlying list to power the badge server and it should be exposed on a site as well.

Existing .NET Foundation projects will be encouraged to join at level three, but we can't force them to. Most of them already meet the criteria given that there's been a reasonably high bar for projects to join the Foundation already.

richlander commented 5 years ago

Right. This is all new, so we're starting off with a clean slate. We'll start registering projects shortly, and get the badge server running.

jongalloway commented 5 years ago

@HurricanKai It looks like everything's been answered here, okay if we close this issue?