Lack of consistency for ECL icons

joarod-eu commented 1 month ago

Expected behavior

Icons must have the same variants in all their versions. Several outline and filled versions are missing. Also two icons have the same design but are declared with two different names.

Actual behavior

Lack of consistency in icon declinations, for example:

Information-round icon has no outline version
Check-filled has no outline version (with the circle)
Warning-round has no outline version
Play icon has no outline version
Minus-outline has no filled version
Log-in-outline and log-in are both outline, but there is no filled version
Multiple-files and copy icon are duplicated with the same design
Arrow, corner-arrow, solid-arrow has only one direction (the other 3 directions are missing, and please don't tell to use CSS to rotate)
Mastodon color is not updated (current color is more violet)
Several Social media icons has the left and bottom side of the circle cut off (ex: spotify-color, spotifym pinterest-color, pinterest-negative, pinterest)

Steps to reproduce the issue

Just go to the Iconography page:
https://ec.europa.eu/component-library/ec/guidelines/iconography/

Extra info

I'm already developing some icons missing to move forward in our web development (DG SANTE), I don't mind to open a PR and add several of the icons missing if that will help. If not, please let me know the right person in the design department to contact and share these svg items. Thanks

emeryro commented 1 month ago

Hello, thanks for your report. We will check that with the designers and come back to you. What I can already tell, is that rotating arrow icons is indeed the way we use them. You can find some helpers for that on ECL website

Out of curiosity, could you tell me more about the usage you have of ECL? As it seems, you are using directly to build your website. I also saw that you forked the project in the past. Are you using a custom version of it? Thanks

joarod-eu commented 4 weeks ago

Hello @emeryro Thanks for your quick reply, let me know if the designers would like to exchange/contact me for the icons I already have.

I will ping you later via Teams to give you more info about the DG Sante platform and framework.

ec-europa / europa-component-library