search

ethereum / ethereum-org-website

Ethereum.org is a primary online resource for the Ethereum community.
https://ethereum.org/
MIT License
5.04k stars 4.77k forks source link

Suggest a wallet: SubWallet #13542

Closed Mabel-Nguyen closed 1 month ago

Mabel-Nguyen commented 1 month ago

Wallet name

SubWallet

What type of wallet?

EOA

Wallet description

SubWallet is the comprehensive non-custodial wallet solution for Polkadot & Ethereum ecosystems. We envision a Web3 multiverse gateway through which users can enjoy multichain services with utmost ease and absolute security.

Wallet logo

Background color for brand logo

004BFF

URL to the project

https://subwallet.app/

When did the wallet go live to users?

2022

What are the fees users may be paying for using your wallet product?

Users don't have to pay any wallet fees to SubWallet. They only need to pay the network and/or protocol fees depending on the transaction.

Does the wallet have an active development team?

Yes, GitHub: https://github.com/Koniverse

Is the wallet globally accessible?

Yes

Is the wallet available in multiple languages?

English, Vietnamese, Japanese, Chinese, Russian

What social links are there for the project?

X (Twitter): https://x.com/subwalletapp Telegram: https://t.me/subwallet Discord: https://discord.com/invite/PvjV5mu6Gq Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC5XYLzQ1G077kUb7guZEMdA

Does the wallet have a mobile app? If yes, which operating systems are supported (iOS, Android)?

Yes, SubWallet Mobile is available for both iOS and Android:

Does the wallet have a desktop app? If yes, which operating systems are supported (Windows, Mac, Linux)?

Yes, SubWallet Web Dashboard works with Windows, Mac, Linux:

Does the wallet have a browser extension? If yes, which browsers are supported (Chromium, Firefox, Safari)?

Yes, SubWallet Browser Extension is available on Chrome, Firefox:

Is it a hardware wallet?

No

What is the availability of your source code?

Open source

What license is the wallet software released under?

Apache-2.0 license; more details here: https://github.com/Koniverse/SubWallet-Extension?tab=Apache-2.0-1-ov-file#readme

Who holds the private keys?

SubWallet is non-custodial. Users have full access to their public and private keys. If the project disappears, users can import their private keys into other crypto wallets to access their funds.

Please describe the measures taken to ensure the wallet's security and provide documentation wherever possible

SubWallet has had two security audits, is open-source, and has integrated some phishing preventions. All security information is listed at: https://www.subwallet.app/security.html

Has the wallet's smart contract code or security modules been audited?

Yes, https://verichains.io/?search=subwallet

Does the wallet have an internal security team?

Not really but we do have a QA/QC team to help ensure that the user experience using SubWallet is as secured as possible.

Any other security testing that should be noted?

All security information is listed at: https://www.subwallet.app/security.html

Scam protection?

Yes, SubWallet has integrated phishing lists from Polkadot {.js} and ChainPatrol to protect users from scams. So when users access a flagged site, they will see a notification. All security information is listed at: https://www.subwallet.app/security.html

Does the wallet support connecting to Ethereum applications?

Yes; Here are the documents about WalletConnect (https://docs.subwallet.app/main/extension-user-guide/connect-dapps-and-manage-website-access/connect-dapp-with-walletconnect), about connecting SubWallet directly (https://docs.subwallet.app/main/extension-user-guide/connect-dapps-and-manage-website-access), and in-wallet browser (https://docs.subwallet.app/main/mobile-app-user-guide/dapp-browser-and-manage-website-access)

Does the wallet support connecting to a hardware wallet?

Yes

Does the wallet support importing Ethereum RPC endpoints?

Yes, https://docs.subwallet.app/main/extension-user-guide/customize-your-networks#import-networks

Does the wallet support viewing and interacting with NFTs?

Yes

Does the wallet support staking directly?

Yes, but only for networks based on the Polkadot-SDK at the moment. Documentation: https://docs.subwallet.app/main/extension-user-guide/manage-staking

Does the wallet support swaps directly?

Yes, here is a quick walk-through for SubWallet's swap feature: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GNrDEHiiPiY

Does the wallet support bridging directly?

Yes, SubWallet supports bridging various tokens between various chains. Here is our user guide: https://docs.subwallet.app/main/extension-user-guide/receive-and-transfer-assets/transfer-tokens/cross-chain-transfer; and here is a tutorial specifically for bridging WETH between Ethereum <> Polkadot: https://x.com/subwalletapp/status/1805601650318700771

Does the wallet support multi-chain networks?

Yes, https://docs.subwallet.app/main/integration/supported-network

Which Ethereum Layer 2 networks does the wallet support?

Arbitrum, Polygon, Optimism, Boba Network, Base

Does the wallet allow the user to customize gas fees?

No

Does the wallet support sending transactions to ENS addresses?

No

Does the wallet support importing or automatically querying and displaying ERC-20 tokens?

Yes, https://docs.subwallet.app/main/extension-user-guide/import-and-manage-customized-assets/import-and-manage-customized-tokens

Does the wallet support EIP-1559 (type 2) transactions?

Yes, SubWallet supports type 2 (EIP-1559) and type 0 (legacy) transactions.

Does the wallet have any recovery options?

Users can export and backup accounts on SubWallet: https://docs.subwallet.app/main/extension-user-guide/account-management/export-and-backup-accounts

Does the wallet have fiat on-ramps through credit/debit cards, wire transfers, or bank transfers (ACH)?

Yes, https://docs.subwallet.app/main/extension-user-guide/buy-crypto-from-fiat-money

Does the wallet support withdrawals to fiat?

Not yet

Is the wallet a multi-signature wallet?

No response

Does the wallet support social recovery?

No response

Does the wallet support bundled transactions?

No

Who can the ethereum.org team can contact regarding the wallet in future?

Mabel - BD at SubWallet

Does the wallet have a dedicated support team?

Yes, SubWallet's community support is available via email, telegram, and discord:

What educational resources/documentation do you provide to users?

Our comprehensive guideline is available at https://docs.subwallet.app/ We also post some detailed tutorials on Youtube at https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC5XYLzQ1G077kUb7guZEMdA

Does the wallet have any integrated tools not mentioned above?

No response

Would you like to work on this issue?

wackerow commented 1 month ago

Thanks @Mabel-Nguyen! Assigned to @konopkja for product review to start

Mabel-Nguyen commented 1 month ago

Thank you! @konopkja please let me know if you need any further information

konopkja commented 1 month ago

Hello @Mabel-Nguyen, after a careful review of both browser app and mobile app I concluded that this wallet is primarily focusing on Polkadot ecosystem, while Ethereum support in the UI is secondary or even hidden.

This would result in a lot of confusion and friction for our Ethereum.org users who's goals are to use Ethereum networks and expect to use wallets that are primarily tailored for Ethereum and its ecosystem.

The default setting, accounts, tokens and dapps are tailored for Polkadot ecosystem instead.

For these reasons I suggest against listing SubWallet.

Mabel-Nguyen commented 1 month ago

Hi @konopkja, I understand your concern! Our team will continue improving SubWallet further so the user experience is simple and easy for Ethereum's ecosystem as well. Thank you so much for your feedback!

konopkja commented 1 month ago

We had a meeting with SubWallet and discussed the next steps to improve Ethereum user experience. Closing this ticket with the expectation of a new ticket in the future, once some change are implemented.