search

eudaldgr / kiss-live

šŸ“€ Script to build livecd iso for KISSLinux
https://kisslinux.org
GNU General Public License v3.0
48 stars 9 forks source link

ISO boot issues #8

Open dilyn-corner opened 3 years ago

dilyn-corner commented 3 years ago

Testing the kde branch šŸ‘šŸ»

Command executed was sudo ./kiss-live -d -k. Seemed to run successfully, I have a built ISO image (and the sha1sum matches). Looking over everything that goes into the creation of this ISO, I should be able to use it on a UEFI system, yes? The usual ways I would go about making a UEFI bootable usb (cat kiss-live-2020.9-2.iso /dev/sda or dd) do not render a bootable USB device; my list of options is blank (this method works fine with an Arch ISO, for comparison). Have you had success using kiss-live with a UEFI system? I have no experience creating ISOs, so I'm not sure where to check on this problem.

Another issue (here) was resolved by installing file on the host. I'd add a check for this when you also check for the other required packages (or find a different way to set $kernver; could just cat repo/linux/version if you don't need all the information given by file).

Outside of that, there isn't a whole lot else I see as being wrong with the kde work you've incorporated here. A few recommendations would be to use the kiss-kde tarball I provide so users don't have to build the entire kde_pkgs list every time they want an ISO; I might have missed the option (you could probably do this through build.cfg?) but using a local tarball instead of starting from scratch would be great in case of failures or incremental updates to the image.

eudaldgr commented 3 years ago

Well, the thing is that i can't test the UEFI on real hardware and in qemu you need some tricky bios files due to boot into UEFI, i do the UEFI things copying what other distros do. So thanks to report, that UEFI doesn't work at all. I'm blind in that sense. But this isn't the first experience with kiss grub and images that don't boot. I tried the kiss-bootstrap script, and if you run inside a KISSLINUX machine the image result don't boots also. With bios boots "well", under qemu and real hardware.

I will see what to do with the file issue, but I assume that is installed because is a util-linux depends, and that is a syslinux depends also. I will work on that.

I will add the tarball option, i might think how (well i need to do a kiss-export <pkg> inside only).

But I want to ask you a question, have you booted well the kiss-kde-live? I mean, mine boots, i see kde splash after login, the wallpaper + cursor, aaaaand that's all, I can't move the cursor, keyboard don't respond, I didn't know if it's freezed or it's working without input devices.

dilyn-corner commented 3 years ago

I don't have qemu setup and I'm not terribly interested in learning how to do so but I'd be more than happy to try! The best way to troublshoot input issues would probably involve launching top when X starts to see what processes are running and if it's frozen or your input is broken. It could be anything from input devices not being setup by xorg or an issue with plasmashell (I have similar bugs when updating qt5; it seems that qt5 only sometimes links to dbus when an update is made? I'm unsure, and it's a problem I'm exploring. Unfortunately rebuilding qt5 until it works isn't a good solution haha).

file wouldn't seem to be a util-linux dep (as I have one installed and not the other).

I'll explore the UEFI requirements further and see what I can find!

dilyn-corner commented 3 years ago

So I mounted the iso to a loopback device and... It's empty? There's nothing there. But it's 252MB in size, so there's something in it...

eudaldgr commented 3 years ago

I'm dumb, file isn't a dep of util-linux.

I tried to launch some apps when I start X, like konsole or dolphin but nothing happens on my laptop, only wallpaper + cursor.

The iso file is empty? No 'boot' or 'pkgs' dir inside? That's weird.

dilyn-corner commented 3 years ago

Unsure what bizarre mistakes were made on my end but after fixing up my kernel and rebooting, the ISO looks like it contains most of the right stuff (comparing to Arch's ISO)... ~I'll have to continue looking at why I can't boot it.~ Was attempting another method of making a UEFI-bootable USB live device and wouldn't you know it, cfdisk tells me the stick has a DOS label. Who gave them the right to manipulate my parition tables like that smh.

As for your issues, there could be a few reasons... Most of them lost to the sands of time (I haven't had a full freeze like that since the first time I tried to launch KDE).

I will work on getting qemu setup on my machine today and test there to see what's up.

dilyn-corner commented 3 years ago

Launched qemu through the run-qemu script; encountered a black screen with an x in the center. My best guess, plasma-shell is crashing.

ucodelukas commented 3 years ago

I have to manually load linux because the linux.mod is in /boot/grub/linux.mod Not /boot/grub/x86_64-efi/linux.mod IMG_20201202_000119.jpg

I have a uefi PC, can test and probably fix stuff

eudaldgr commented 3 years ago

@ucodelukas that screenshot is from the kde branch?

ucodelukas commented 3 years ago

that is the iso you provide in Releases

eudaldgr commented 3 years ago

That issue is opened about the 'kde branch'. Thanks for the report, but this isn't related to this issue.

ucodelukas commented 3 years ago

is firmware and a properly configured kernel there? if not, we are working on one

ucodelukas commented 3 years ago

can someone post the recent kde iso? i will try to find out why

also, efi works, some tests go on tho

eudaldgr commented 3 years ago

@dilyn-corner I made some changes, and now the livecd it's EFI-bootable (tested on real hardware), and made some changes to work with your tarball. I guess that would be sufficient. I'm testing now.

dilyn-corner commented 3 years ago

Sorry I've been AWOL, other projects caught my eye and I've been tearing my hair out solving the problems that arose. I'll give your new work a test this week and report back. Y'all are great <3