search

fedora-infra / fmn

A system for generic fedmsg-driven notifications for end users.
25 stars 30 forks source link

Could it sending meeting minutes automatically to mailinglist? #48

Closed tvvocold closed 9 years ago

tvvocold commented 9 years ago

In https://apps.fedoraproject.org/notifications/myid.id.fedoraproject.org/email/ : My active filter is "All messages matching a regular expression" &" A particular user's packages" and "All IRC meeting events" , and i test it in #fedora-zh, but couldn't get email when i #endmeeting. (I can forward the noti-email to mailling list by add a filter in Gmail) Why and how to fix?

tvvocold commented 9 years ago

@ralphbean

ralphbean commented 9 years ago

Hi @tvvocold. The issue I think is that, for a message to be delivered it must match all rules on the filter and there's no way as far as I know to have a message that is both about an irc meeting and about a package. (Packages are not inherently part of irc meeting events).

In order to advise further, I'll need to know what your regular expression is for. Can you explain it?

Ultimately, you're probably going to have to make a few separate filters:

Let me know what the regex is for and maybe we can figure out something more conclusive.

tvvocold commented 9 years ago

Hi @ralphbean Thx for answer. and here is my filter: (as u can see,i had disable the packages and other filters,what i need is that fedora-app-noti-email send me mails with the irc meeting minutes so that i can forward it to mailing list (by add a filer in gmail), What should i do next?) Thx! image

FYI: Till now(i test it by startmeeting and endmeeting in fedora-zh) i could not got the noti-mails.

ralphbean commented 9 years ago

You have to re-enable that 'github' filter with the 'All IRC meeting events' filter. That should send emails about all irc meetings to you. But that's not quite what you want.

I would edit that filter, delete the 'All IRC meeting events' rule, and add a new rule just for the end of meetings, (when the minutes are available).

I'd then add a second rule to the filter with a regex looking for (fedora-zh) so that you only get messages about fedora-zh meetings (and not all the other meetings that go on).

ralphbean commented 9 years ago

I'm going to close this for now. Please re-open if you have problems with it.

tvvocold commented 9 years ago

Well, i do not think that would work, i need a automatically server for send meeting minutes to mailing list, so could u modefi the irc fliter to send ALL meeting logs to mail? BTW, it seems the All irc meeting event" rule does't work very well (or server doesn't work very well) (i only got 1-2 mails about whatever meetings in 1-2 weeks till now)

ralphbean commented 9 years ago

could u modefi the irc fliter to send ALL meeting logs to mail?

Yes, you could have it do that by just using the 'All irc events' rule.

it seems the All irc meeting event" rule does't work very well (or server doesn't work very well) (i only got 1-2 mails about whatever meetings in 1-2 weeks till now

But, (this is based on your screenshot), you had it disabled. It shouldn't have sent any in that case.

tvvocold commented 9 years ago

in fact i enable it , and u can try it in that sites. see if u can got meeting mails.(with all meeting logs)

ralphbean commented 9 years ago

with all meeting logs

Heh, this part will be working soon. The code is here, https://github.com/fedora-infra/fedmsg_meta_fedora_infrastructure/commit/7baa7c9fdcdc3093596496a60d354ef96071ac49 -- it just needs to be deployed to the server still. Hopefully today.

tvvocold commented 9 years ago

Nice! that would be wonderful! Thx! BTW, plz fix the server too, seems like it did't work very well(Maybe the gmail somehow block some mails from server?)

tvvocold commented 9 years ago

@ralphbean Hi,sry to bother u , but is this thing( to send meeting minutes automatically to mailinglist) working now in https://apps.fedoraproject.org/notifications?

ralphbean commented 9 years ago

@tvvocold should be, yes. What are you seeing?

tvvocold commented 9 years ago

i cannot find that... it seems the All irc meeting event" rule isn't what i need.

tvvocold commented 9 years ago

@ralphbean Can u reopen this issue Since there is NO sending meeting minutes to maillist feature. What i got is

Mailing list emails
Including this rule will trigger a notification anytime an email is POSTED to any Fedora Project mailman3 list.

but what i am looking for is sending meeting minutes like （#fedora-admin) to maillist

ralphbean commented 9 years ago

Sure. Will re-open it. Again I'm fairly sure that it can be done with the present pieces. Will have to verify and get back to you.

ralphbean commented 9 years ago

@tvvocold btw, we got this working for sending emails to the meetingminutes list in #72.

ralphbean commented 9 years ago

The configuration looks like this:

fmn-meeting-minutes

tvvocold commented 9 years ago

Cool! but just one rule? how can i specify a irc channel like #fedora-zh? And i need to use list mail to sign up tha FAS?

ralphbean commented 9 years ago

Cool! but just one rule?

Yeah! In this case, we want to forward all meetings in all channels to the meetingminutes list, so just one rule is needed.

how can i specify a irc channel like #fedora-zh?

You would combine that one rule with a second rule for 'All messages matching a regular expression'. You could just put fedora-zh in for the pattern there.

And i need to use list mail to sign up tha FAS?

This was the trickiest part. You would need to put the mailing list address into FMN, yes, and then confirm the subscription.

tvvocold commented 9 years ago

So i add a second rule for 'All messages matching a regular expression' and i got 3 noti-emails when i endmeeting:

1, tvvocold started a meeting in #fedora-zh
2, tvvocold raised a point of information in a meeting in #fedora-zh: "Just a test."
3, Meeting started by tvvocold at 01:33:18 UTC. The full logs are available

but i just need the third mail.

Update: Now i got a new mail:

tvvocold commented on issue #48 on fedora-infra/fmn

Anyidea?

ralphbean commented 9 years ago

Sounds like you added two filters each with one rule. I think you need one filter with two rules attached to it.

tvvocold commented 9 years ago

OK, cool. I think that would be even cooler if it work with IFTTT

ralphbean commented 9 years ago

If the fmn site allowed you to create custom RSS feeds, that would do it, right? (the issue for that is #37).

tvvocold commented 9 years ago

I mean by use ifttt, we can push the noti-msg to phone or something else.(not just emails or irc). That's even cool! FYI: There is a wheel for create custom RSS feeds.

pypingou commented 9 years ago

Is feed43 FOSS?