search

froala / angular-froala-wysiwyg

Angular 4, 5, 6, 7, 8 and 9 plugin for Froala WYSIWYG HTML Rich Text Editor.
https://froala.com/wysiwyg-editor
735 stars 202 forks source link

Support for Angular 16 and Ivy #518

Closed scurk1415 closed 1 year ago

scurk1415 commented 1 year ago

The legacy ViewEngine has been deprecated and removed in Angular 16.

Please add support for Ivy compiler, as you library now breaks, with Angular 16 and blocks me from updating to the newest Angular

This likely means that the library (angular-froala-wysiwyg) which declares FroalaEditorModule is not compatible with Angular Ivy. Check if a newer version of the library is available, and update if so. Also consider checking with the library's authors to see if the library is expected to be compatible with Ivy.

Versions: Angular: 16.0.0 angular-froala-wysiwyg: 4.0.18

Someone already made a PR for this https://github.com/froala/angular-froala-wysiwyg/pull/509

canadakickass commented 1 year ago

Our team needs this.

IchigoWalker commented 1 year ago

need this ASAP since Angular 16 is already there for a month

ptomaszi commented 1 year ago

We are in the same position. We cannot upgrade to Angular 16 because of the IVY support missing. Please resolve ASAP.

lana-white commented 1 year ago

This is very limiting, not being up to date with the latest, and now considering another editor. There is not much point in Froala existing if you don't update with the latest releases of Angular!

CinkadeusBG commented 1 year ago

Likewise. Currently seeking alternative option.

karam1ashqar commented 1 year ago

@harasunu-narayan can we push this

ilyaskarim commented 1 year ago

We have already escalated this matter internally and our development team is currently reviewing it with high priority. We expect to provide an update on this issue by early next week.

jofrly commented 1 year ago

We have already escalated this matter internally and our development team is currently reviewing it with high priority. We expect to provide an update on this issue by early next week.

Is there a timeline for this? This blocks our upgrade to Angular 16 too.

Vitalyua commented 1 year ago

Dear Team, please update on status and any estimated timelines for Angular 16 support?

fexxdev commented 1 year ago

Yes please, it would be great to know some kind of ETA as our enterprise app is using Froala and we would love to update asap. Thanks!

osahner commented 1 year ago

Can we please get an update, now? Otherwise, we will have to look for alternatives.

rlunaro commented 1 year ago

I am havin the same problem.

osahner commented 1 year ago

I had problems with angular v16 so I did my own fork and upgraded up to v16 and switched to standalone components.
https://github.com/osahner/angular-froala-wysiwyg/tree/upgrade-to-ivy

ilyaskarim commented 1 year ago

We have already escalated this matter internally and our development team is currently reviewing it with high priority. We expect to provide an update on this issue by early next week.

We'll be releasing the fix for this issue in our framework upgrade on 11th July.

osahner commented 1 year ago

... and now please publish the release :)

sanchit-wizni commented 1 year ago

@ilyaskarim any update on this?

Pajchel commented 1 year ago

@ilyaskarim any update when the update will be added into release please? We really need the latest release ASAP. Thanks Tomas

Vitalyua commented 1 year ago

Dear Team, any ETA for Solution?

VassilTonev commented 1 year ago

I couldn't help, but smile while reading all the comments. Just 2 weeks ago the Froala team finally announced typescript definitions for the library. The issue for those was opened on Nov 22, 2017 (yes, you read it correctly, 2017).

I am really interested to see, how long it will take to release an IVY-build - something, which they should've done already, because it was more that clear that this painful moment will come, when we are not able to use the cool Angular v16 features, because we are stuck with Froala, which is a nice editor, to be fair.

Of course I am not that naive to think that older versions (we are still using 3.1.1) will get an IVY-build too.

Dear Froala team, consider this a friendly feedback. You cannot expect from you customers to tolerate this much longer.

EDIT: Just now I am realizing that the v4.1.0 release is not just adding type definitions, but also supporting IVY. However it seems like there are some major issues.

osahner commented 1 year ago

I couldn't help, but smile while reading all the comments. Just 2 weeks ago the Froala team finally announced typescript definitions for the library. The issue for those was opened on Nov 22, 2017 (yes, you read it correctly, 2017).

... Dear Froala team, consider this a friendly feedback. You cannot expect from you customers to tolerate this much longer.

100%

ilyaskarim commented 1 year ago

I couldn't help, but smile while reading all the comments. Just 2 weeks ago the Froala team finally announced typescript definitions for the library. The issue for those was opened on Nov 22, 2017 (yes, you read it correctly, 2017).

I am really interested to see, how long it will take to release an IVY-build - something, which they should've done already, because it was more that clear that this painful moment will come, when we are not able to use the cool Angular v16 features, because we are stuck with Froala, which is a nice editor, to be fair.

Of course I am not that naive to think that older versions (we are still using 3.1.1) will get an IVY-build too.

Dear Froala team, consider this a friendly feedback. You cannot expect from you customers to tolerate this much longer.

EDIT: Just now I am realizing that the v4.1.0 release is not just adding type definitions, but also supporting IVY. However it seems like there are some major issues.

Thank you for taking the time to share your feedback. We completely understand your frustration with the delayed release of Typescript definitions and the IVY build for Froala. You're right that these updates have taken far too long, and I sincerely apologize for the difficulties this has caused you and other customers.
I'm very happy to let you know that we have been working diligently to resolve these issues. Froala v4.1.0 did include initial support for IVY and Typescript definitions. While there were some major issues initially, I'm pleased to say that v4.1.1 has been released and addresses the key problems with the Typescript definitions. Please Refer: https://froala.com/wysiwyg-editor/changelog/#4.1.1