ftyers / UD_Classical_Nahuatl-FloCo

GNU Affero General Public License v3.0
5 stars 1 forks source link

Book 05: Sentence 001 #14

Closed ftyers closed 10 months ago

ftyers commented 10 months ago

imatge

# sent_id = Book_05_-_The_Omens.txt:1
# text = Jc macujlli amuxtli, vncan moteneoa: in tetzaujtl catca, in qujtetzammatia, in iehoantin mexica.
# text[norm] = Ic macuilli amoxtli, oncan motenehua: in tetzahuitl catca, in quitetzammatia, in yehhuantin mexica.
# text[orig] = Jc·macujlli·amuxtli·,·vncan·mo¶teneoa·:·intetzaujtl·catca·,·inqujte¶tzammatia·,·in·iehoantin·mexica·.
# text[eng] = Fifth book, here is told, that which was the omen, that they took to be an omen, they, the Mexica.
# text[osp] = Libro quinto, que habla de los agueros: que esta gente mexicana _.
# text[spa] = Libro quinto, que trata de los agüeros y pronósticos que estos naturales tomaban de algunas aves, animales, y sabandijas, para adivinar las cosas futuras.
# references = A&D/160:1
1   Jc  ic  ADV _   _   3   amod    _   Folio=1r|Paragraph=1|Line=1|Norm=Ic
2   macujlli    macuilli    NUM _   _   1   nummod  _   Folio=1r|Paragraph=1|Line=1|Norm=macuilli|Gloss=cinco
3   amuxtli amoxtli NOUN    _   State=Abs   6   obl _   Folio=1r|Paragraph=1|Line=1|Norm=amoxtli|Gloss=libro|Analysed=Yes
4   ,   ,   PUNCT   _       6   punct   _   Folio=1r|Paragraph=1|Line=1|Norm=,|Analysed=Yes
5   vncan   oncan   ADV _       6   advmod  _   Folio=1r|Paragraph=1|Line=1|Norm=oncan|Gloss=aquí|Analysed=Yes
6   moteneoa    tenehua VERB    _   Number[subj]=Plur,Sing|Person[subj]=3|Reflexive[obj]=Yes|Subcat=Tran|Tense=Pres|VerbForm=Fin    0   root    _   Orig=mo¶·teneoa|Folio=1r,1r|Paragraph=1,1|Line=1,2|Norm=motenehua|AmbigNorm=True|Override=False|Analysed=Yes
7   :   :   PUNCT   _       8   punct   _   Folio=1r|Paragraph=1|Line=2|Norm=:|Analysed=Yes
8   in  in  PRON    _   _   6   nsubj   _   Orig=intetzaujtl|Folio=1r|Paragraph=1|Line=2|Norm=in
9   tetzaujtl   tetzahuitl  NOUN    _   State=Abs   8   acl _   Orig=intetzaujtl|Folio=1r|Paragraph=1|Line=2|Norm=tetzahuitl|Analysed=Yes
10  catca   catqui  VERB    _   Subcat=Intr 9   cop _   Folio=1r|Paragraph=1|Line=2|Norm=catca
11  ,   ,   PUNCT   _       13  punct   _   Folio=1r|Paragraph=1|Line=2|Norm=,|Analysed=Yes
12  in  in  SCONJ   _   _   13  mark    _   Orig=inqujte¶·tzammatia|Folio=1r,1r|Paragraph=1,1|Line=2,3|Norm=in
13  qujtetzammatia  tetzammatia VERB    _   Number[obj]=Sing|Number[subj]=Plur,Sing|Person[obj]=3|Person[subj]=3|Subcat=Tran|Tense=Pres|VerbForm=Fin    9   acl_Orig=inqujte¶·tzammatia|Folio=1r,1r|Paragraph=1,1|Line=2,3|Norm=quitetzammatia|Analysed=Yes
14  ,   ,   PUNCT   _       16  punct   _   Folio=1r|Paragraph=1|Line=3|Norm=,|Analysed=Yes
15  in  in  DET _   _   16  det _   Folio=1r|Paragraph=1|Line=3|Norm=in
16  iehoantin   yehhuan PRON    _   Number=Plur|Person=3|PronType=Prs   13  nsubj   _   Folio=1r|Paragraph=1|Line=3|Norm=yehhuantin|Gloss=ellos|Analysed=Yes
17  mexica  mexicatl    NOUN    _   Number=Plur 16  appos   _   Folio=1r|Paragraph=1|Line=3|Norm=mexica|Analysed=Yes
18  .   .   PUNCT   _       6   punct   _   Folio=1r|Paragraph=1|Line=3|Norm=.|Analysed=Yes
ftyers commented 10 months ago

Cross check annotation of ordinal structure.

ftyers commented 10 months ago

Questions:

ftyers commented 10 months ago

Re: in yehhuantin mexica (Andrews, p.420)

imatge

Lguyogiro commented 10 months ago

Re: in yehhuantin mexica (Andrews, p.420)

the appos analysis in the original is :+1:

ftyers commented 10 months ago

imatge

WDYT?

Lguyogiro commented 10 months ago

I think in this case we should have conj from tetzahuitl to quitetzammatia, since they both could be clausal subjects of motenehua. This is different from the case of parataxis:shared we have previously discussed, since here both clauses act as subject to the same verb (vs. to clauses that share an argument).

Lguyogiro commented 10 months ago

for posterity:

Is catca a copula? (see also https://github.com/ftyers/UD_Classical_Nahuatl-FloCo/issues/5)

Yes

What is the structure of in yehhuantin mexicah ?

What is the structure of motenehua in tetzahuitl catca

in tetzahuitl catca is clausal subject of motenehua

We have three ins, what are their functions, what is their structure?: