geohci / edit-types

Edit diffs and type detection for Wikipedia
MIT License
12 stars 3 forks source link

Consider Template subcategories (and potentially other nodes) #18

Closed geohci closed 8 months ago

geohci commented 2 years ago

Right now, edits to templates are described per the same, high-level actions as other nodes -- i.e. insert / remove / change / move. Like Text, however, there are likely subcategories of Template edits that we care about -- e.g., how many parameters changed and which ones? We should consider defining a taxonomy of Template edit types and determining what it would mean to be able to distinguish between these different types.

The reason for distinguishing between these subtypes (beyond more info = better for some applications) is that certain actions have very different patrolling implications or difficulties depending on what was done. For example, changing a link destination could be a sneaky form of vandalism and editing captions is a specific (and difficult) need on the wikis around accessibility/understanding; there are lots of different table actions but changing the header row generally has no different implications/difficulty than changing a data row.

Other potential nodes with rich sub-types:

geohci commented 8 months ago

this is addressed now in the fine-grained changes in treediffer