agraef
commented
5 years ago Here's my suggested fix for faust2jaqt:
--- /usr/bin/faust2jaqt 2019-03-08 10:44:06.000000000 +0100
+++ faust2jaqt 2019-03-08 12:54:26.787644378 +0100
@@ -169,7 +169,7 @@
(
cd "$TMP"
$QMAKE -project "QT += widgets printsupport network" "CONFIG+=warn_off" "$CLANGOPT" "INCLUDEPATH+=$CUR" "INCLUDEPATH+=$FAUSTINC /opt/local/include" "QMAKE_CXXFLAGS=$CXXFLAGS -Wno-unused-parameter $FAUSTTOOLSFLAGS" "LIBS+=$ARCHLIB $SOUNDFILELIBS $OSCLIBS $HTTPLIBS" "HEADERS+=$FAUSTINC/faust/gui/QTUI.h" "RESOURCES+= $FAUSTINC/faust/gui/Styles/Grey.qrc" "$OSCDEFS" "$HTTPDEFS" "$QRDEFS" "$POLYDEFS" "$MIDIDEFS" "$SOUNDFILEDEFS"
- $QMAKE $SPEC
+ $QMAKE $SPEC QMAKE_CFLAGS_ISYSTEM=-I
make
) > /dev/null || exitThis seems to work fine with both Qt4 and Qt 5.12, but I haven't tested it for any earlier version of Qt5 or any other gcc version than 8.2.
Similarly, the following does the trick for FaustLive:
diff --git a/Build/Makefile b/Build/Makefile
index c6ea50d..bb41095 100644
--- a/Build/Makefile
+++ b/Build/Makefile
@@ -52,10 +52,10 @@ windows:
@echo Proceed manually.
qmake:
- cd $(OUTDIR) && qmake .. $(SPEC)
+ cd $(OUTDIR) && qmake .. $(SPEC) QMAKE_CFLAGS_ISYSTEM=-I
$(OUTDIR)/Makefile : $(OUTDIR) FaustLive.pro
- cd $(OUTDIR) && qmake .. $(SPEC)
+ cd $(OUTDIR) && qmake .. $(SPEC) QMAKE_CFLAGS_ISYSTEM=-I
$(OUTDIR) :
mkdir $(OUTDIR)
sletz
There is a problem with compiling Faust dsps using faust2jaqt, as well as compiling FaustLive, when using the latest gcc and Qt versions. I'm currently running gcc 8.2 and Qt 5.12 on Arch, but it seems that the issue has been around for a while now, at least since gcc 8.1 and Qt 5.10.
Here's what I get when I compile any Faust dsp source (using the latest faust from git) with faust2jaqt:
Similarly, when compiling FaustLive (latest from git, running
makein the Build directory):In either case, compiling against Qt4 works fine, and with Qt5 I can make the errors go away when adding the setting
QMAKE_CFLAGS_ISYSTEM=-Ito each qmake command (following the advice at https://github.com/machinekit/QtQuickVcp/issues/278).This issue seems to be for real, and not just some local misconfiguration on my system. Just google for
cstdlib:75:15: fatal error: stdlib.h: No such file or directory, it's all over the place, so many people using Arch and other systems with recent gcc and Qt versions are running into this. As the issue cited above indicates, developers are patching their sources to deal with it.The root cause seems to be that qmake now spits out
-isystemoptions instead of-Ifor their includes (anything onINCLUDEPATH), for whatever reason. If an application usesINCLUDEPATHand includes system directories in there (specifically/usr/include), as faust2jaqt and FaustLive do, this wreaks havoc on gcc's system include paths so that g++ doesn't find stuff in/usr/includeany more if the g++ system headers use#include_nextto include the headers. So it's probably a bad interaction between Qt 5.10+ and either gcc itself or the g++ system headers. UsingQMAKE_CFLAGS_ISYSTEM=-Iwith qmake works around the issue.The question is what to do about it. Maybe we're supposed to stop using
INCLUDEPATHin the way we do? Can anyone with more insight on the latest Qt developments shed some light on this?If there's no immediate solution other than the suggested workaround, should we handle this upstream or should we rely on package maintainers to work around the issue? (That would be me and David in the case of Arch.) The thing is, if we just ignore this issue upstream, then it will come around to bite us on mainstream Linux distros rather sooner than later, so I think that we need to figure out what's really going on here and act on it in some way.