search

gravitl / netmaker

Netmaker makes networks with WireGuard. Netmaker automates fast, secure, and distributed virtual networks.
https://netmaker.io
Other
9.4k stars 547 forks source link

[Bug]: Failed to create client ingress cannot be created on nodes behind NAT #2747

Closed EricFROL closed 9 months ago

EricFROL commented 9 months ago

Contact Details

No response

What happened?

Just decided to set up netmaker. I have followed all previous steps fine, until I need to set up Ingress + External Clients. Adding any of my three connected hosts as a client returns me this alert as a popup (they all are on the same local network):

Failed to create client
ingress cannot be created on nodes behind NAT

Am I doing something wrong?

Version

v0.20.2

What OS are you using?

Linux, Windows

Relevant log output

No response

Contributing guidelines

unquietwiki commented 9 months ago

@EricFROL I saw this come up on the Discord, and had a thought. If the ingress node is behind a firewall, are you able to forward TCP & UDP 51821-51831 to it? Or if it's something like a home connection, are you able to designate the ingress as a DMZ target?

abhishek9686 commented 9 months ago

@EricFROL we don't block ingress creation even if host is behind NAT, on the UI we just show a warning, so I am not sure from where exactly are you getting this response can you confirm your server version again?

EricFROL commented 9 months ago

@unquietwiki I currently have firewall disabled, so that can't be... how can I designate the ingress as a dmz target??

@abhishek9686 yes, v0.20.2

abhishek9686 commented 9 months ago

@unquietwiki I currently have firewall disabled, so that can't be... how can I designate the ingress as a dmz target??

@abhishek9686 yes, v0.20.2

okay that's an old version, this check has been removed in newer versions

EricFROL commented 9 months ago

Well that's the version stated in https://docs.netmaker.io/quick-start.html. Should I put latest?

abhishek9686 commented 9 months ago

Well that's the version that is stated in https://docs.netmaker.io/quick-start.html. Should I put latest?

we are updating the docs, use v0.21.2

EricFROL commented 9 months ago

Closing as working on v0.21.2. Thank you.