search

itplr-kosit / validator-configuration-xrechnung

Configuration for validating documents against the German XRechnung standard using the KoSIT validation tool
https://xeinkauf.de/xrechnung/
Apache License 2.0
58 stars 15 forks source link

What is the practical difference of report valid and accept recommendation? #32

Closed christian-schlichtherle closed 3 years ago

christian-schlichtherle commented 4 years ago

Between...

https://github.com/itplr-kosit/validator-configuration-xrechnung/blob/1e62a804f8c3d049be6b1e5ffc405fdb8891f777/scenarios.xml#L76

and...

<acceptMatch>/rep:report[@valid='true']</acceptMatch>

It seems the latter is a bit more concise.

rkottmann commented 3 years ago

The difference is the whole difference why the validator exists: /rep:report[@valid='true'] is about the technical validation results (XSD and schematron errors) and the <acceptMatch>/rep:report/rep:assessment[1]/rep:accept[1]</acceptMatch> is about the result of computing an rep:accept recomendation based on the technical validation results and the customizations of severity levels in scenario.xml.

Hope this answers your question. Otherwise, pls feel free to re-open.

christian-schlichtherle commented 3 years ago

So if the severity levels are not customized, then the following holds true?

exists(/rep:report[@valid='true']) = exists(/rep:report/rep:assessment[1]/rep:accept[1])
rkottmann commented 3 years ago

yes