jonescompneurolab / hnn-tutorials

2 stars 7 forks source link

Gamma tutorial issues #17

Open asoplata opened 4 days ago

asoplata commented 4 days ago

There are a few outstanding issues with the new CoreGUI Gamma tutorial specifically:

There is a step missing between Figure 11 and Figure 12. This section may have to be partially rewritten. If I follow the CoreGUI tutorial exactly, instead of Figure 12, I get the following output:

Screenshot_20241126_102218

This appears to be due to a difference in the tonic drive strength. In the original tutorial https://jonescompneurolab.github.io/hnn-tutorials/gamma/gamma near Figure 11, the L5 Pyr tonic drive is set to 6.0 nA (but in the newest CoreGUI tutorial, it is only set to 2.0 nA). If I make the changes necessary for the gamma_L5weak_tonic_02 simulation in the CoreGUI tutorial, but ALSO increase the L5 Pyr tonic drive from 2 to 6, only then do I get the output exactly as shown in Figure 12.A:

Screenshot_20241126_102207

Screenshot_20241126_110731

dylansdaniels commented 3 days ago

Sounds like the right path forward on all items. I think you're totally right that there's a step missing between Figs 11/12