jontio / JAERO

Demodulate and decode Aero signals. These signals contain SatCom ACARS messages as used by planes beyond VHF ACARS range
https://jontio.zapto.org/hda1/jaero.html
MIT License
224 stars 39 forks source link

include background information #8

Open axd1967 opened 8 years ago

axd1967 commented 8 years ago

hello,

your pages are hugely interesting, to the point you could consider including them as a documentation source for the program.

as example, I've forked and created a first page here: https://github.com/axd1967/JAERO/blob/contrib/doc/doc/README.md

an alternative could be the wiki, but the advantage of including the doc is that the doc can nicely evolve together with code evolutions, while the wiki - even if it is also a Git repository - is independent.

if you like the idea, I can add the other hda1/ pages and send you a pull request, or if you prefer, I will drop the fork.

maybe a few more suggestions? I guess you are aware of these, yet allow me to suggest them:

rgds

-alex-

(FYI, I use PyCharm as Markdown editor)

(and I wrote this before stumbling over your http://jontio.zapto.org/software-and-hardware/webpagesetup.html ;-) )

jontio commented 8 years ago

Hi Alex,

Thanks for the ideas. Documentation with the source sounds reasonable. I like writing using my jontio.zapto.org website as I do things so divergence between the documentation in the source and my web site could be a problem as well as the extra work required updating two places were documentation resides.

I was always hoping that people would add pages to the wiki to create documentation but that hasn’t happened yet. I like the wiki idea as then people can easily add and change things without me.

I think http://jontio.zapto.org/hda1/jaero.html reads more like a log and something more “getting started” manual like might be more appropriate to include in the source repository.

However, due to personal circumstances I won’t be working on my website, documentation or JAERO for a few months at least.

Cheers,

Jonti

From: alex [mailto:notifications@github.com] Sent: Thursday, 5 May 2016 9:55 p.m. To: jontio/JAERO Subject: [jontio/JAERO] include background information (#8)

hello,

your pages http://jontio.zapto.org/hda1/jaero.html are hugely interesting, to the point you could consider including them as a documentation source for the program.

as example, I've forked and created a first page here: https://github.com/axd1967/JAERO/blob/contrib/doc/doc/README.md

an alternative could be the wiki, but the advantage of including the doc is that the doc can nicely evolve together with code evolutions, while the wiki - even if it is also a Git repository - is independent.

if you like the idea, I can add the other hda1/ pages and send you a pull request, or if you prefer, I will drop the fork.

maybe a few more suggestions? I guess you are aware of these, yet allow me to suggest them:

rgds

-alex-

(FYI, I use PyCharm as Markdown editor)

— You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread. Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub https://github.com/jontio/JAERO/issues/8 https://github.com/notifications/beacon/ANCOA8qJDyLD6tARl10n1SgauZ_akiu6ks5p-b6CgaJpZM4IX5Ly.gif

axd1967 commented 8 years ago

hello @jontio

(BTW, there is no big difference between a wiki and normal pages - except maybe that the wiki allows for more easy diffing.)

IMHO I don't think the wiki will take off as a crowdsourced place to gather documentation.

And I suspect that - unless there is much activity around your app - a "getting started" manual will not materialise (one reason being it needs time, and you already indicated that would be an issue, so someone else needs to take that initiative). Just keeping the repo up-to-date with your findings make sit easier for others to get those changes (and discover the diffs) via git pull - a kind of (slightly more expensive) RSS/mailing list. But again, you already have tools and website, so I understand the choice is not easy.

I'll leave the fork for now, maybe it will generate more ideas; please contact/mention me if you want me to remove it.

rgds, -alex-