search

khenriks / mp3fs

FUSE-based transcoding filesystem from FLAC to MP3
http://khenriks.github.io/mp3fs/
GNU General Public License v3.0
382 stars 46 forks source link

OGG Support #1

Open khenriks opened 12 years ago

khenriks commented 12 years ago

Add support for the Ogg Vorbis audio files.

GrandGrunt commented 12 years ago

I would also welcome the support of Ogg Vorbis for mp3fs.

If someone writes a patch for Vorbis, would it be accepted ?

khenriks commented 12 years ago

It's going to be awkward to add OGG support without restructuring the code. I'm in the process of doing this, but it's not done yet. Once it is done, then work to add OGG support can begin.

So I can't accept any patches yet, but afterwards I probably would, at least as a starting point.

bluemoehre commented 12 years ago

Looking forward for this feature due HTML5 in FF and Opera does only support OGG =/

eliasp commented 12 years ago

This bug isn't very clear about whether to add support for Ogg Vorbis for the source files or for the output files. Care to elaborate (although I'd love to see both)?

khenriks commented 12 years ago

This was intentionally vague, as I want to leave open the possibility for both. Source file Ogg support is certainly reasonable. Source file support for Ogg will likely come before output file support.

bluemoehre commented 11 years ago

i would like to "transcode" from FLAC to OGG Vorbis to meet the HTML5 specs

lpirl commented 11 years ago

I'd also very welcome OGG I/O for ideological reasons. :) Best Regards & big "thank you" for mp3fs!

ghost commented 11 years ago

Same here though not neccessarily for input. Output Vorbis (and OPUS) would be nice.

khenriks commented 11 years ago

Since there seems to be a lot of interest, I just though I'd post an update on where things stand. The code has now been rewritten to make it more modular, so that there's a natural way to add Vorbis (or Opus) support at this point. I don't know when I will actually write the code to do so, but there isn't anything now standing in the way of it.

nigels-com commented 10 years ago

Sounds interesting. I would indeed like to use mp3fs to layer on top of my collection of mp3, ogg and flac files. Transcoding from ogg to mp3 on the fly would be a great thing indeed, for completeness.

bobek commented 10 years ago

+1 for @nigels-com comment on ogg -> mp3. I do store flac still having a log of ogg files. But some players do support mp3 only... Naturally one can transcode all oggs to flac for storage purposes, but it just seems weired.