krzysk1 / optica

Edgley EA-7 Optica for Aerofly FS4
GNU General Public License v3.0
2 stars 0 forks source link

RIghtWingAero Flap0Area and Flap1Area Undefined #3

Closed jayeye2011 closed 1 year ago

jayeye2011 commented 1 year ago
            <[float64][Flap0Area][0.300]>
            <[float64][Flap1Area][0.300]>

Are not present in the RightWingAero block Not sure if this is an issue, although deploying flaps up to 50 degrees does seem to cause a tendency to roll to the right. <[aerowing][LeftWingAero][] <[string8][Body][LeftWing]> <[float64][Span][6.000]> <[float64][Area][8.400]> <[string8][Flap0Control][ServoLeftAileron.Output]> <[string8][Flap1Control][ServoFlaps.Output]> <[float64array][StationY] [ 0.000 1.798 3.595 5.992 ]> <[float64array][StationLE] [ 0.455 0.440 0.425 0.405 ]> <[float64array][StationTE] [ -1.045 -1.000 -0.955 -0.895 ]> <[float64array][StationZ] [ -0.090 0.004 0.098 0.224 ]> <[float64array][StationIncidence] [ 0.087 0.000 0.000 0.000 ]> <[uint32array][StationFlap] [ 0 2 1 0 ]> <[float64array][StationFlapFraction][ 0.00 0.30 0.30 0.00 ]> <[float64][AspectRatioMultiplier][2.0]> <[string8][AirfoilRoot][AirfoilRoot]> <[string8][AirfoilTip][AirfoilTip]> <[float64][Flap0Area][0.300]> <[float64][Flap1Area][0.300]> <[string8][DownWashInput][LeftWingAero.DownWashMean]> <[float64][DownWashPercentage][1.00]> <[float64][GroundEffectFactor][1.00]> <[float64][GroundEffectScale][1.00]>

But these two parameters are not present in the <[aerowing][RightWingAero][] <[string8][Body][RightWing]> <[string8][Flap0Control][ServoRightAileron.Output]> <[string8][Flap1Control][ServoFlaps.Output]> <[float64array][StationY] [ -5.992 -3.595 -1.798 0.000 ]> <[float64array][StationLE] [ 0.405 0.425 0.440 0.455 ]> <[float64array][StationTE] [ -0.895 -0.955 -1.000 -1.045 ]> <[float64array][StationZ] [ 0.224 0.098 0 0.004 -0.090 ]> <[float64array][StationIncidence] [ 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.087 ]> <[uint32array][StationFlap] [ 1 2 0 0 ]> <[float64array][StationFlapFraction][ 0.30 0.30 0.00 0.00 ]> <[float64][AspectRatioMultiplier][2.0]> <[string8][AirfoilRoot][AirfoilRoot]> <[string8][AirfoilTip][AirfoilTip]> <[string8][DownWashInput][RightWingAero.DownWashMean]> <[float64][DownWashPercentage][1.00]> <[float64][GroundEffectFactor][1.00]> <[float64][GroundEffectScale][1.00]>

jayeye2011 commented 1 year ago

I think the Flap0Area and Flap1Area duplicate the StationFlapFraction array and were probably deprecated in FS2 since there is no actual text description of what they are in the Wiki. I suggest removing them from LeftAeroWing rather than adding them to RightAeroWing. But leaving it unchanged with on wing having and the other not does induce a significant right roll effect when flaps are set to maximum 50 degrees. Edit: Note that right now, the Optical has an a slight tendency to roll left at all times when flaps are at 0 degrees. I guess that is just P-factor or something since propwash settings are negligeble.

jayeye2011 commented 1 year ago

After removing the Flap0Area and Flap1Area defines from LeftWingAero this corrected the induce right roll when flaps fully deployed. Also the current Github optica.tmd still generates the following when maintaining constant altitude 20230107051953_1 The Wikipedia specs for EA-7 Maximum speed: 213 km/h (132 mph, 115 kn) Cruise speed: 130 km/h (81 mph, 70 kn) (loiter speed, 40% power) Stall speed: 108 km/h (67 mph, 58 kn) outboard flaps up Never exceed speed: 259 km/h (161 mph, 140 kn)

krzysk1 commented 1 year ago

Flap0Area and Flap1Area are deprecated, indeed. StationFlapFraction is used instead of. Span and Area are deprecated as well

jayeye2011 commented 1 year ago

It is important to remove <[float64][Flap0Area][0.300]> <[float64][Flap1Area][0.300]> from the left wing. Since even though deprecated, if one wing has it defined while the other does not it does impact the flight model negatively in that deploying flaps induces and unbalance lift on the left wing causing the aircraft to roll to the right.

krzysk1 commented 1 year ago

be removed next version

jayeye2011 commented 1 year ago

be removed next version

good enough